Who Deserves Your Loyalty?

Rewards programs are getting increasingly stingy. The experts weigh in with their favorites.

The consensus among business-travel experts--who follow rewards programs very closely--is that the programs are getting increasingly stingy. And yet, as the actual experience varies little from one airline or hotel to another, some companies aim to differentiate themselves through their rewards programs.

The experts (myself included) weigh in with their favorites.

David Rowell
thetravelinsider.info
Rowell, who lives in Seattle and flies Alaska Airlines often, is a fan of the carrier's program because of "the broad range of airline partners for earning and awards." Members can earn and redeem miles with 15 airlines, including American, British Airways, Continental, Delta, KLM, Northwest, and Qantas. "It's been many years since I've taken a flight that didn't award Alaska miles," he says.

Keith L. Alexander
The Washington Post
Alexander casts his vote for generosity, wherever he finds it: "Any airline program where the miles don't expire is a good one." With most legacy airline programs, any time you earn or redeem miles, all account miles are extended for three years. Credits earned in JetBlue's program, on the other hand, disappear after one year. "It's hard enough to redeem miles," says Alexander. "You shouldn't have to worry about losing them."

Joe Sharkey
The New York Times
Avis does the simple things well, according to Sharkey, with decent prices, a simple booking process, and routine upgrades. "I don't have to go to a lot of trouble to get my car," he says. "My reservation is always on a rack ready to go, and there's often a Wall Street Journal on the driver's seat--a nice touch. Consequently, I don't really shop around."

Randy Petersen
insideflyer.com
InterContinental's "Any Hotel, Anywhere" awards option, which allows you to exchange points for prepaid lodging cards redeemable at any hotel that takes American Express, is a favorite of Petersen's. "It lets me get away from chain hotels altogether and stay at a B&B in Napa Valley," he says.

Christopher Elliott
tripso.com
Southwest Airlines began restricting awards seats in February; before that, a member would automatically be awarded a seat as long as the requested flight wasn't sold out. Even after the change, Elliott thinks highly of the carrier's program. "I haven't heard a single complaint," he says. "The program is easy, straightforward, and transparent. The airline must be doing something right."

Tim Winship
frequentflier.com
"With 1,500 partners, American's AAdvantage program offers more opportunities to earn miles than any other," says Winship. As for hotels, he belongs to the Marriott Rewards program: "I'm a fan of the chain's Courtyard by Marriott. The free high-speed Internet access, the work-friendly rooms, and the reasonable rates are a winning combo."

Ed Perkins
Contributing editor to smartertravel.com
National Car Rental offers a benefit that drivers of a fussy disposition (which Perkins says he is) find endearing: At most locations, members renting midsize cars can head straight out to the lot and pick out their exact vehicle. "That's special," he says. "It gives me a reason to rent from National."

Perkins favors Hilton for putting elite status within relatively easy reach. Guests hit the mark after 10 nights or four separate stays in a 12-month period. To reach elite status with Marriott, meanwhile, you must stay 10 nights; with InterContinental, you need to stay 15 nights or amass 20,000 points; and with Starwood, the requirement is 10 stays or 25 nights.

Joe Brancatelli
joesentme.com
"I'm truly impressed with how Continental's website allows members to view available awards seats day by day, flight by flight," says Brancatelli. But as for which carrier most often delivers on the promise of free seats, he singles out American. "They do it best. I've had great luck getting awards seats on American, even last minute." Among hotels, Brancatelli prefers Starwood because you can trade in points for deluxe accommodations, such as New York's St. Regis Hotel. "This isn't for lightweights," he says, noting that it takes 20,000--25,000 points for a single night's stay there.


Free downloadable wallet card
DOWNLOADABLE WALLET CARDS
Give them to your friends! Just download the handy card, print it out, and cut on the dotted lines. If you don't already have it, you will need Adobe Acrobat, a free (and easy!) plug-in, to read the cards
  • Download the wallet card
  • Download Adobe Acrobat
  • Note:This story was accurate when it was published. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.
     
    Follow Us!

    Booking Tool

    Check Current Prices

    1. Hotels
    2. Flights
    3. Cars
    4. Cruises

    Choose Sites

    Choose Sites

    Choose Sites

    Choose Sites

    Travel Tips

    Tagged
    Planning
    354257

    Note the expiration dates of any debit or credit cards you plan on using while you're away. In Budapest, I tried to withdraw cash with my ATM card, only to find that it had expired just days before.

    — Matt Vance
    Tagged
    Solo Travel
    553595

    In areas where the majority of people don't speak English, head to an Internet café. In our experience, they're full of friendly young people anxious to practice their English.

    — Christine and Duncan Orr
    Tagged
    Technology
    427291

    Quotetravelinsurance.com gives you comparable details on more than one hundred travel-insurance plans, enabling you to make the best buy. It relies on ratings from insurance industry overseers such as A.M. Best and state insurance commissioners before allowing an insurance company into its extensive lineup.

    — Marc Oppy
    Tagged
    Packing
    365260

    Batteries for cameras, laptops, cell phones, and other devices can be charged at night in your hotel room. But if you're doing a lot of driving, you might want to buy an inverter to charge them while on the road. Inverters (which plug into the car's cigarette lighter) are small, inexpensive, and can be purchased at auto-supply, variety, or electronics stores.

    — Kay Euhus
    Tagged
    Safety
    442310

    In order to keep track of my bags, I use a small metal bell--the kind dancers from India wear on their ankles. I thread it with fishing line and tie it to my carry-on. If anyone touches my bag after I set it down, the bell chimes. It's not a very obtrusive sound, but it's distinctive enough for me to notice if a thief is trying to get into my things. The same bell can be hung on the doorknob inside your hotel room.

    — Jim Hall
    Tagged
    Dining
    372278

    To feed a family of four in a very expensive tropical location like Anguilla or Bermuda (or most other Caribbean locations, for that matter), check to see if your hotel has phone books and look up the local pizza place. Nine times out of ten the pizza purveyors will deliver for free. You'll end up spending no more than $20 on pizza, bread sticks, and soda.

    — Bianca Mims
    Tagged
    Packing
    366260

    Restrooms abroad rarely have hooks on stall doors. Our solution: Pack a small S hook in your shoulder bag and make use of a hole in the wall, a pipe, etc., to hang purses, jackets, or anything else you want to keep off the floor. S hooks can be found in most hardware stores, near the screws and bolts.

    — Arthur and Marie Lloyd
    Tagged
    Dining
    361257

    In North American cities with large Chinese communities, choose a family-run Chinese restaurant and ask for the set family meals, usually written in Chinese. They are more authentic than those typically offered to tourists and people who are not Chinese—not to mention a better value. In San Francisco, for example, you can enjoy a five-course meal, which easily feeds a family of four, for less than $20.

    — Winston Wong
    Tagged
    Cruises
    387319

    If your vacation spot is a major port of call for cruise ships, plan excursions for the days that the ships aren't docked. Tours will be less crowded, and you'll get to see and do a lot more.

    — Krista Fowles
    Tagged
    Planning
    360254

    If you're divorced and plan to travel out of the country with your children, check the legal requirements in advance. When I tried to take my kids to Cancun, I learned too late that Mexico requires a notarized letter of consent signed by both parents for minors traveling alone or with one parent or guardian. If the parents are divorced, a copy of the parental custody agreement is allowed instead. The airlines enforce this rule before you get on the plane.

    — Marge Stratton
    Tagged
    Planning
    364282

    Before traveling overseas, look at your health insurance card. If it only shows an 800 or 888 number for precertification of hospital admissions, call that number and obtain the local number with an area code. Many 800 numbers can't be dialed from foreign countries. I learned this the hard way during an emergency hospital admission in Switzerland. The delay in reaching my carrier could have been avoided.

    — Chris Carveth
    Tagged
    Photography
    447630

    Carry a Polaroid camera when traveling to developing countries. In Cambodia, several village children gathered around us, posed enthusiastically for pictures, and were fascinated by their images in our digital camera. We wanted to send them the pictures, but they were unable to tell us their address. Polaroids would have solved the problem!

    — Cynda Perun
    Tagged
    Hotels
    452344

    When I called to book a hotel room in Budapest, I was offered a rate of $75 per night. After I told the concierge that I was looking for a room in the $35 range, he agreed to the lower price without much fuss. It sometimes pays to barter.

    — Julie Jensen
    Tagged
    Hotels
    447353

    I always bring a small flashlight to hotels in case there's a blackout. The building may not be equipped with emergency lighting, and, if necessary, my flashlight will help me quickly locate the nearest exit.

    — Lois Meshonek
    Tagged
    Transportation
    386246

    Driving around Italy last summer, my husband and I found that even the most detailed maps left us scratching our heads in confusion. Desperate and lost, we decided to follow a tour bus. Guess what? It got us exactly where we wanted to go.

    — Cindy Marcus
    Tagged
    Solo Travel
    367275

    If you're traveling solo and want some company for dinner, try the sushi bar at a Japanese restaurant. It's a great place to meet locals. Plus, you'll receive extra attention and special recommendations from the chef.

    — Marcie Rubenstein
    Tagged
    Packing
    341240

    Recycle the long plastic bags in which you receive your home-delivered newspapers. Slip your shoes into the bags before packing them in your suitcase.

    — Robert E. Jones
    Tagged
    Hotels
    426335

    Flight attendants often work vampire hours and have to sleep during the day. How do we keep the sunlight from leaking into our hotel rooms? We clip a skirt hanger (or two) to the middle of the drapes to seal them together.

    — Elisabeth Joyce
    Tagged
    Packing
    380271

    Baby wipes aren't just for babies. Slip a travel-size pack into your carry-on bag and use the wipes to kill germs on public toilet seats and in phone booths. In a pinch, they can also remove stubborn stains from clothing.

    — Farrah Farhang
    Tagged
    Packing
    377267

    If the zipper on your luggage or your clothing is giving you any trouble, rubbing some lip balm or candle wax onto the teeth should loosen it.

    — Marko Anderson
    Tagged
    Car Rentals
    382259

    When renting a car, photograph any damage the car may have before leaving the rental agency; a digital camera records the date and time of each picture. On a recent trip to Argentina, I rented a car with extensive paint damage. When I returned the car, the agency attempted to blame me for the scratches. I showed them my photographs, and they rescinded their accusations.

    — Richard L. Garcia
    Tagged
    Packing
    356241

    Everyone knows that duct tape is great for helping out in travel emergencies, but no one wants to lug around a bulky roll of the stuff. By wrapping a few feet onto a pencil or ballpoint pen, you'll get a miniature roll that does not take up much in the way of additional space.

    — Randy Hartselle
    Tagged
    Planning
    385236

    Before setting off on one of my many backpacking excursions, I head to Kinko's to rebind my guidebook. I replace the cover with a plain black or navy one. It costs about $6 and allows me to blend in much better while traveling. People see my new book as a journal, not a travel guide that labels me a tourist.

    — Michelle Johnson
    Tagged
    Packing
    338273

    Pack a power strip and extension cord for your next cruise. Many cruise-ship cabins have only one out- let, but you'll definitely need more if you want to power up your laptop, iPod, cell phone, electric razor, hairdryer, or any other gadgets you bring on board.

    — Jay Van Vechten
    Tagged
    Car Rentals
    362255

    Online check-in isn't just for airlines. After reserving an Alamo car over the Internet, I was offered online check-in just by entering my credit card number and driver's license information for approval. At the airport, following Alamo's instructions, I informed the shuttle-bus driver that I had checked in online and reserved an economy car. I was dropped off in the lot and told to pick whichever car I wanted. I drove it to the exit, where my credit card and driver's license were verified on the computer, and I was done.

    — Brad Cook
    Tagged
    Planning
    388254

    I've discovered a wonderful way to enjoy massages at a fraction of the usual cost. Some massage-training schools provide superb service in a spa-type environment. Do a Google search to see if there are training programs near your next vacation destination.

    — Karen Gardiner
    Tagged
    Cruises
    373300

    Make your cabin homier by packing a small collapsible vase and a bouquet of flowers.

    — Martha and Ken Wiseman
    Tagged
    Packing
    358263

    Attach a few carabiners--the kind of clips rock climbers use--to the top of your wheeled suitcase. Purses, cameras, and shopping bags can be clipped to your suitcase, giving your hands and shoulders a rest while you're walking around the airport.

    — Kathryn Murphy
    Tagged
    Planning
    369270

    If you're headed to a country that requires a visa, ask the consulate of that country, in the United States, whether visas are also issued at the airport there on arrival. In many cases (like Turkey and Egypt), they are. Obtaining the visa on arrival is a much simpler procedure and a real money-saver: You do not have to have photographs taken (they figure your passport already has a photo), you do not pay a hefty fee to the U.S.-situated consulate of the country, you avoid the expense and risk of mailing your passport to that consulate in advance of departure, and you avoid the expense of using a visa-acquiring company in the United States. But be sure the consulate is correct that the visa can easily be obtained on arrival.

    — Carmencita Soriano
    Tagged
    Technology
    394272

    Check out worldclimate.com to find monthly average temperatures and rainfall for thousands of cities worldwide. You can avoid countries during their rainy seasons, and the information is useful for figuring out what to pack.

    — Elizabeth Bass

    Custom Search

    Select the details relevant to your trip to see a list of articles that match your needs — it's the best way to get ideas!
    SELECT YOUR DESTINATION
    SELECT YOUR ACTIVITIES