TEST LAB

The Best Wheelie Bags

There have been big advances in wheelie-bag technology (particularly the wheels). Since it's hard to test a bag before you buy it, we did the dirty work for you.

(Morgan & Owens)

It might be time to buy a new wheelie bag. But the question is, which one? We asked manufacturers to let us test out medium-size models with the newest, most durable, smoothest-riding wheels. We considered testing carry-ons, but good wheels seem more important on larger bags.

The perfect bag needs wheels large enough to roll easily over uneven terrain like cobblestones and sidewalk cracks, yet not so big that they're obtrusive. They have to be soft, to lessen vibration and noise, and at the same time durable enough to survive dozens of vacations. Ideally, the bag will be able to zigzag quickly through crowds and corner like a Corvette--and yet be stable enough to avoid wobbling around on one wheel or tipping over entirely.

Before testing these five models, we loaded each with 40 pounds of clothes, so that they'd total about 50 pounds apiece, the maximum for free checked bags on airlines. As for the lab coats--we couldn't resist.

Rating system

Excellent *****
Good ****
Average ***
Fair **
Poor *

The contenders

Tumi T-Tech Pulse Cooper Square 30" tumi.com, $450
Ogio Terminal 28" ogio.com, $170
REI Strato Cruiser 25" rei.com, $230
Osprey Vector 28" ospreypacks.com, $189
Eagle Creek Velocity 25" eaglecreek.com,$340

Test 1: The slalom

The closest we could get to a mad dash through a crowded airport.

It immediately became clear how much better these bags are than what rolled around airports 10 years ago. We felt like Bode Miller on a good day: All the wheels were remarkably quiet and cruised smoothly across the pavement. The Osprey, with its big 3.5-inch wheels, was the smoothest of all, while the REI's 16-inch wheelbase (the widest of the bunch) kept it especially stable. None of the bags came close to tipping during turns, and switching directions was a breeze. The Tumi got a slight demerit because it felt a little heavier and clunkier.

The slalom

Eagle Creek *****
Ogio ****½
Osprey *****
REI *****
Tumi ****

Test 2: Cornering

City streets are mean enough. The last thing anyone needs is a bag that can't handle the turns.

This was where the bags really began differentiating. The three with the widest wheelbases--REI, Eagle Creek, and Tumi--remained on two wheels without a hiccup while zipping around corners. The Eagle Creek and the REI were somewhat more likely than the Tumi to go up on one wheel or flip when cornering during a near sprint. The Ogio and the Osprey, on the other hand--which have wheelbases of 13.5 and 13 inches, respectively--often leaned over on one wheel when entering a corner at any pace faster than a walk. At jogging speed, they flipped over regularly.

Cornering

Eagle Creek ****½
Ogio *
Osprey *
REI ****½
Tumi *****

Test 3: Bumpy terrain

Because any wheelie bag can glide right over smooth floors.

The Tumi rode like a Cadillac over cobblestones, uneven concrete, and stone walkways; the Eagle Creek absorbed the bumps and handled the terrain even better. Neither came close to tipping, even on some hairy sections of banked cobblestone. Either of the bags sure would come in handy for touring medieval towns in Europe. The REI performed adequately, though it bounced more and rode a little rougher over the bumpiest areas. The Osprey and the Ogio sailed over the cobblestones and sidewalk cracks if pulled in a straight line, but both were likely to tip up on one wheel and flop over when riding over lopsided sections of stone.

Bumpy terrain

Eagle Creek *****
Ogio **
Osprey ***
REI ****½
Tumi ****½

Test 4: Curbhopping

There will always be times when your bag has to make a leap.

We yanked the bags up curbs and small sets of stairs again and again to see how the bags handled the impact. Sometimes we hit the curb dead on; other times we made contact at a slight angle. The Tumi was the smoothest curb hopper, easing its way up and absorbing the steps as well as you could expect. The Eagle Creek, REI, and Tumi quickly settled back on two wheels when hitting the curb at an awkward angle. The Osprey easily jumped up curbs and stairs, but its big wheels caused more of a jolt than the others. Both the Ogio and the Osprey were inclined to flip when we hit the curb at anything other than a 90-degree angle.

Note:This story was accurate when it was published. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.
 

Article Comments

Please log in to post comments/ratings

Rate this article

Comment on this article

(Limit 5000 characters / 5000 characters remaining)

Overall Rating:

Follow Us!

Booking Tool

Check Current Prices

  1. Hotels
  2. Flights
  3. Cars
  4. Cruises

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Travel Tips

Tagged
Packing
331286

Always carry peanut butter. A plastic jar is easy to pack, doesn't need refrigeration, is a great source of protein, and makes a quick, cheap meal when coupled with local bread. (But don't forget to pack a plastic knife for spreading it.)

— Nancy Norman
Tagged
Packing
323269

To ensure the studs of pierced and delicate earrings don't get damaged, I put them in a film canister. An added benefit is that they're less likely to be stolen when left in a suitcase or hotel room, because thieves presume there's nothing inside but film.

— Alison Taylor Fastov
Tagged
Hotels
401352

Before you buy expensive bottled water from your hotel room minibar, head to the fitness center. You'll be able to fill up an empty bottle at the gym's water cooler or fountain for free, and you don't need to break a sweat.

— Amanda Geraci
Tagged
Packing
356285

My husband cut an old contact lens case in two and uses the halves to carry his medication when we're traveling. He prefers them to regular pillboxes because lens cases are watertight and compact enough to carry inside a shirt pocket.

— Jean Holtmann
Tagged
Photography
345273

I always snap photographs of scenic highway markers, park entrance signs, and the like. These informational photos are put into our album to help identify the many sites that we visited.

— Betty L. Cox
Tagged
Road Trips
370337

For our road trip through the English countryside, I printed out a detailed map for every location we wanted to visit from multimap.com. I labeled each map with the day we planned on using it and wrote down the interesting sites and places to eat along the way. I kept them all in a folder and added brochures from the places we saw. It was a great souvenir upon returning home.

— Karen Holt
Tagged
Hotels
388322

Cold-weather traveling means turning up the thermostat in your hotel room, and along with the artificially warmed air come dry skin and static electricity. Instead of turning on the heat, fill the bathtub with very hot water and leave the bathroom door open. In about an hour, your entire room will be warm and humidified.

— Susan Mutty
Tagged
Planning
334262

I live in coastal Florida, where the electricity sometimes goes out during violent storms. Before a trip, I place a few ice cubes in a plastic bag and put the bag in the freezer. If the ice has melted and refrozen by the time I get home, I'll know we've had a power outage and that any food left in the refrigerator may be unsafe to consume.

— Brigitte Emick
Tagged
Planning
335237

Know your PINs! My husband and I left home with very little cash on us, and instead of stopping to get money at the airport, my husband--ever the procrastinator--decided to wait until we got to Cancún to use his ATM card. Guess what? It didn't work in any of the machines. And although he had several credit cards for cash advances, he didn't know the PINs off the top of his head. We charged everything we could during our stay, but most of the markets don't take credit cards. Needless to say, I didn't come home with a lot of souvenirs.

— CaSandra Knight
Tagged
Loyalty Programs
346270

Before using frequent-flier miles, investigate how much the flight actually costs. For example, it takes at least 25,000 miles per person to travel from Boston to Alaska. The same flight cost us $288. After paying for our tickets, we received enough additional miles to travel for free to Sweden instead of Alaska!

— Bobby Pellant
Tagged
Car Rentals
328255

I always have problems locating my rental car in a large parking lot. Now I bring along a brightly colored bandanna and tie it to the antenna.

— Tamara Johnson
Tagged
Safety
415306

Traveling to non-English-speaking countries can be daunting for people with food allergies. Find someone fluent in the local language to write out what you are allergic to, the seriousness of the allergy (we had a friend include the phrase "this could kill me"), and what to do if you fall ill.

— M. Thompson and K.A. Fares Bannon
Tagged
Family Travel
350273

Give your children a coach's whistle in case they get lost; put it on a ribbon so they can wear it around their neck. The piercing sound may be annoying, but you'll definitely find them quicker!

— Chandra Huang
Tagged
Hotels
398306

Try getting a discount on your hotel room by offering to pay in cash. A hotel reservationist suggested this approach when I phoned to reserve at a hotel in London. I asked if the hotel could grant a discount based on my AARP or AAA membership, as many hotels do in the United States. Her response was that the only discount she was able to offer was 10 percent if I paid in cash.

— Joan Nikelsky
Tagged
Packing
331255

My husband and I are retired, and we take two trips abroad each year. When unpacking, I put items we use repeatedly on each trip (flashlight, alarm clock, travel-size toiletries, etc.) into a box and keep it stored near the suitcases. No more searching or trying to remember if I've got everything for the next journey—it's all in one place.

— Mary Meikle
Tagged
Dining
343246

If you're looking for authentic street food--whether you're in New York or Bangkok--don't buy from the pitifully lonely vendor who has no customers. Head to the cart with the longest line of hungry people in front of it. Locals know which vendors serve the best (and safest) food. Even if you have to wait, your stomach will thank you.

— Bryan Thao Worra
Tagged
Packing
346273

Instead of bringing one of those bungee cables to hang-dry my delicates and socks, I pack a couple of mini plastic hangers--the ones that bras and panties come on when you buy them. They take up very little room in my luggage and can be thrown away at the end of the trip.

— Monica Pileggi
Tagged
Hotels
393326

Flight attendants often work vampire hours and have to sleep during the day. How do we keep the sunlight from leaking into our hotel rooms? We clip a skirt hanger (or two) to the middle of the drapes to seal them together.

— Elisabeth Joyce
Tagged
Packing
352262

If the zipper on your luggage or your clothing is giving you any trouble, rubbing some lip balm or candle wax onto the teeth should loosen it.

— Marko Anderson
Tagged
Technology
371286

Don't put your magnetic sunglass clip-ons in the same pocket as your mass transit fare cards or hotel key cards. I managed to erase both my subway pass and my hotel key on a recent trip.

— Jim Tichenor
Tagged
Shopping
328257

It helps to have a calculator if you plan to do a lot of shopping in foreign markets. When you find something you like, hand the seller the calculator and ask him to enter his best price. It's easy to convert the response into dollars so you know what you're spending. If necessary, the calculator can be used to haggle, especially if you don't speak the language.

— Becky Sapp
Tagged
Dining
325253

I carry bilingual takeout menus when traveling to countries like China, Korea, and Vietnam. When I'm at a restaurant with no menu (or one that I can't read), I give mine to the waiter so he can point to dishes they can prepare. I've learned to pack a few extra menus, as the restaurants often like to keep a copy.

— Charles Locher
Tagged
Car Rentals
321260

Whenever I know I'll be renting a car, I pack a couple of folded paper towels and two small spray bottles--one filled with window cleaner and the other with Rain-X, a product that repels raindrops. It's hard enough driving an unfamiliar car in an unfamiliar location. At least with a clean windshield I'm able to see properly, no matter the weather.

— Ed Rainer
Tagged
Planning
346248

If you're traveling overseas, be sure to check the fine print concerning passports (go online or call the country's embassy). I had three months before my passport expired and found out at the last minute that I needed six months' leeway to enter Tahiti. Luckily, I was able to get a new passport just in time for my vacation.

— Jean Schwinn
Tagged
Technology
367268

After I fell into a stream in Cambodia, my digital camera wouldn't work. Someone suggested leaving the camera in a bag of rice overnight to draw out any condensation. By the next morning, it was dry and working perfectly.

— Roger Bailey
Tagged
Car Rentals
326262

When booking a rental car online, click on "special offers" or "hot deals" to find the company's current promotional codes. Price your reservation using each code. Also, keep in mind that rates fluctuate according to seasons and slow periods. I managed to save more than $170 on a ten-day rental in Orlando, Fla.,by changing my reservation dates twice and by using different codes.

— Jeff Thomsen
Tagged
Planning
356248

I teach a Tulane University seminar on independent European travel for first-timers. Until recently, I advocated Europe's great rail networks as the way to go. Now, with the plethora of budget airlines, I recommend a combination of the two. But it makes the planning stage—which I find almost as much fun as actually taking the trip—more involved. Thank goodness for whichbudget.com, a Web site that lists, by city, which budget airlines serve which cities. Then, to find links to all of Europe's state railway Web sites, visit railfaneurope.net. Each site generally features a travel planner and, almost invariably, an English-language option.

— Brian Hughes
Tagged
Transportation
322245

My husband and I always travel around Europe by train. When we arrive in any city, we first stop at a ticket window and get all the information we'll need for the next leg of our journey. This gives us plenty of time to find an English-speaking ticket agent who'll print out departure times and platform numbers for us. Before leaving the station, we can note the location of the platform we'll be looking for that morning. One wrong move when you're rushing for a train and you could end up in the wrong city!

— Betty Lynn
Tagged
Shopping
345248

When you're shopping for alcohol on any Caribbean island, ask if there's a Kmart nearby. Often the dis- counter is a short distance from the docks where the cruise ships tie up and has an extensive selection at prices lower than the liquor stores on the main drag. While you're there, pick up that extra roll of film or the sunscreen you forgot.

— Andrea Mansfield
Tagged
Packing
332264

Pack a couple of mountaineering carabiners. Clip one through the handle or strap of your bag and secure it to something solid wherever you may be (to a bench in the park or in a train station, to the railing of an overhead compartment on a bus, etc.).The carabiner adds a bit of security, especially if you're snoozing.

— R. Bryan Simon

Custom Search

Select the details relevant to your trip to see a list of articles that match your needs — it's the best way to get ideas!
SELECT YOUR DESTINATION
SELECT YOUR ACTIVITIES