The Ecolodge Authority

What's the most reliable resource when you're seeking a low-impact, spotlessly responsible place to stay? We asked three environmental bloggers to be the judge.

From left: Fodor's Green Travel, Green Places to Stay, and The Eco-Travel Guide
From left: Fodor's Green Travel, Green Places to Stay, and The Eco-Travel Guide

*Top pick!
A green star goes to the guidebook that our judges find most useful.


Jessica Root
Blogs for the websites and She lives in Brooklyn.

Avital Binshtock
A resident of San Francisco, edits the Sierra Club's magazine and its Green Life blog.

Katharine Wroth
An editor for the eco-site She telecommutes from her home outside Boston.


Fodor's Green Travel ($22)

Jessica Root: * The guide is a breeze to navigate and full of amazing photos. Plus, it has two things I love: a price key organizing hotels by "budget," "moderate," and "blow out," and an estimate of the amount of emissions it takes to fly to each one from New York.

Avital Binshtock: Some properties put more of a focus on social responsibility (hiring locals) than on environmental concerns—a bit secondary for a book purporting to list eco-hotels exclusively. Still, it does include some fantastic far-out spots, such as a yoga retreat in a Sri Lankan village.

Katharine Wroth: * The editors did their homework, with nice how-to-save details throughout. For instance, at the Bloomfield House in England, guests get a 10 percent discount if they arrive by bus or by train. It's the closest any of the three comes to being a bona fide travel guide.

Green Places to Stay ($22)

Jessica Root: Certain travel tips are stale: Minimize waste by reusing plastic bags! And the writing is far from smart—describing a hotel called Anna's House in Northern Ireland, the author gushes that "creative energy streams into their green crusade." Why pollute with mixed metaphors?

Avital Binshtock: This little caveat on page 46 made it difficult for me to take any of the reviews seriously: "Owners pay to appear in this guide." And then on the next page: "We make no claims to pure objectivity." I'm glad they differentiated between pure objectivity and the not-so-genuine kind.

Katharine Wroth: Dirt-cheap hostels and luxury lodges are listed cheek by jowl, which can make it frustrating to find a place in your price range. But my biggest complaint is the lack of listings for the U.S.—the closest the book gets to our mainland is the Virgin Islands!

The Eco-Travel Guide ($30)

Jessica Root: Best reserved for a Sunday morning when you have time to wade through the incredible amount of information. And they didn't edit for topicality, either. I have beef with the section on clothing and gear; a few items, like soccer balls and salad servers, were completely unrelated to travel.

Avital Binshtock: * The content is well researched and highly original, with interesting nuggets on new, affordable forms of transportation, such as micro scooters and solar-powered trains. Overall, it deftly walks a fine line; it's dense with detail, yet never boring.

Katharine Wroth: A bulky book that reads like an academic tome, with advice that borders on the unhelpful. It says, for example, that meeting people online is a good substitute for traveling. Thanks! Another problem: The section on green products comes across like an extended advertorial.

Get Inspired with more from

Note:This story was accurate when it was published. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.

Budget Travel Real Deals

  • From $186
  • From $3,084

See more deals »


Our newsletter delivers vacation inspiration straight to your inbox.

Check Prices