New York's Best Antiques and Vintage In 'The Curious Shopper's Guide to New York City,' author Pamela Keech offers tips on where to find the best Bakelite jewelry, Asian furniture and mid-century modern lighting. Read an excerpt Budget Travel Tuesday, Nov 21, 2006, 4:30 PM (Rebecca Simpson) Budget Travel LLC, 2016


New York's Best Antiques and Vintage

In 'The Curious Shopper's Guide to New York City,' author Pamela Keech offers tips on where to find the best Bakelite jewelry, Asian furniture and mid-century modern lighting. Read an excerpt

(Rebecca Simpson)
(Rebecca Simpson)

 Antiques and Vintage Stores 
 24th and 25th sts. from Fifth to Seventh aves.  
 F, V to 23rd St.

The history of this area is one of mixed usage. After the Civil War, Boss Tweed, supported by the votes of the area's Irish immigrants, made the area into a profitable center for vice that became known as the Tenderloin. In 1885, one-half of all buildings in the Tenderloin were reputed to house illegal activities.

In about 1910, loft buildings began to replace the boardinghouses, flophouses, and brothels. A few years later, film production studios located on 26th Street west of Seventh Avenue; Mary Pickford made Tess of the Storm Country (1914) in an old armory on West 26th Street. Light industry, stores that sold industrial sewing machines, and Samuel French Dramatics Company (still there) were among the other assorted enterprises.

Thunder Bay Antiques, Ltd. 
 134 W. 24th St. (Ave. of the Americas/Seventh Ave.)  
 Tues.-Sun. 11 A.M.-7 P.M.; closed Mon. 
 What to look for: Asian and Middle Eastern antiques

Thunder Bay is filled with idiosyncratic antiques, many from Asia. You'll find golden Buddhas, painted tables, and benches from Rajasthan, cabinets from Indonesia, daybeds from China, and armoires from Morocco alongside a few other African pieces, in addition to an occasional early American or Federal piece. A popular new line, Thunder Barn Ltdl, is custom furniture made in upstate New York from wood salvaged from old barns. Recent paintings by African and graffiti artists are displayed with earlier works by known and unknown painters. In-house design, refinishing, and restoration services are offered. In-stock antique items are pictured, and can be ordered, on the website; catalog is also available. Domestic shipping is free.

Olde Good Things 
 124 W. 24th St. (Ave. of the Americas/Seventh Ave.)  
 Daily 9 A.M.-7 P.M. 
 What to look for: architectural antiques

The "architecturologists" (as the staff members call themselves) at Olde Good Things follow wrecking balls all over North and South America in pursuit of architectural antiques. The 24th Street store has four levels filled with chandeliers, balustrades, lock sets, sinks, faucets, doors, windows, desks, statues, display cabinets, and much more. From an impossibly heavy sixteenth-century limestone mantel found in a Connecticut mansion to a sweet one-inch lock plate from the Plaza Hotel, the store displays a vast array of artifacts, including stained glass pieces and chestnut flooring--two categories that are increasingly difficult to find.

The firm has stores in multiple locations and a huge central warehouse in Scranton, Pennsylvania. More than two thousand items are available on the website. Prices are not always firm; some items have a "make an offer" button. Shipping is calculated on a per-item basis. There is a ten-day return policy.

This 'n' That Collectables 
 124 W. 25th St. (Ave. of the Americas/Seventh Ave.)  
 Daily 10 A.M.-6 P.M. 
 What to look for: vintage costume jewelry

The Bakelite in the window of This 'n' That is enough to weaken the knees of the most seasoned collector of vintage costume jewelry. The highly sought-after early plastic was invented in New York City in 1907 by a Belgian chemist, Dr. Leo Baekeland. It was used to make bracelets, flatware handles, and radio cases. It also was used, less familiarly, for the distributor head and cap in the Model A Ford, for the floor beneath the dancing feet of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers in the film Top Hat, and, experimentally, for lightweight coffins during World War II.

Anita Stern, the owner of This 'n' That, has been collecting Bakelite jewelry since the 1950s, when she was a teen-ager and bought it at Woolworth's. She also offers a dazzling array of vintage designer pieces by Trifari, Schiaparelli, Ciner, Miriam Haskell, and Coro, and contemporary designer pieces by Laura Cardillo, Barbera, and Lawrence Vrba. The shop glitters with thousands of crystals and rhinestones, Lucite and Bakelite necklaces are heaped around the necks of mannequins, and stacks of cases hold jewelry categorized by color, material, or motif. The labels on one stack of pin trays read "Butterflys/Bows/Crowns/Birds/Bugs & Flies."

Pamela Keech answered your New York City shopping questions in a chat session on Nov. 28, 2006. Read the transcript!

Get Inspired with more from

Note:This story was accurate when it was published. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.

Budget Travel Real Deals

  • From $1,078
  • From $3,084

See more deals »


Our newsletter delivers vacation inspiration straight to your inbox.

Check Prices