As airlines cut their service to Europe, how to save on fares?

By Sean O'Neill
October 3, 2012
blog_ryanair_wing_original.jpg
Courtesy <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/razee/405665060/" target="_blank">*razee*/Flickr</a>

Delta said yesterday it will chop its flight schedule to Europe by at least 11 percent. United and American are also reducing service across the Atlantic. One bright spot: Most of the cutbacks won't happen until early fall, so bargain fares will still be around for your summer vacation.

What to do if you're flying after August? One trick is The Two Ticket Solution, which means splitting your trip into separate legs and buying round-trip tickets on different airlines for each leg. That's easier than it sounds. An example will make it clear:

Fly to New York City on a discount airline, then fly into Dublin on low cost Irish carrier Aer Lingus, and then take Ryanair to your final destination. It may be a hassle, but you could save hundreds of dollars—especially as U.S. airlines reduce their international flights to drive up ticket prices.

Say you'd like to fly to Barcelona. Book a flight to Dublin first, and then hop a Ryanair flight to Spain's Costa Brava airport. That airport's 55 miles from Barcelona, but a cheap and speedy train link will take you downtown.

Now compare the recent prices for a trip to Barcelona from Los Angeles in early September with a Saturday departure, using Kayak to check prices:

Not using Ryanair:

$1,091 round-trip ticket from LAX on Continental (with one stop at JFK) to Barcelona's Girona Airport.

Using Ryanair:

$766 total, for a $635 for round-trip ticket on Lufthansa between LAX and Dublin plus $53 for a round-trip ticket between Dublin and Costa Brava. Airport plus taxes and fees (about $40) plus a fee for checking one bag ($38) plus a $18 round-trip train ticket between the airport and downtown.

In this example, you would save roughly $300 per person by booking two tickets instead of one.

Note: The Two Ticket Solution is a non-controversial strategy, making it different from back-to-back ticketing, which is a strategy that involves throwing away part of a ticket—which airlines forbid.

Here are some guidelines for deciding when The Two Ticket Solution is worth the hassle:

• Flying to London or Paris? Just book a direct flight. I've never found enough savings to justify the hassle of The Two Ticket Solution for these capital cities. Even with the airlines cutting some service to both London and Paris, there will still be enough planes and you'll find plenty of deals on direct flights. (However, you might consider flying out of New York City, which often has competitive fares. Now that Southwest expects to be flying to La Guardia airport by this summer, a fare war into New York City from many smaller U.S. airports may be in the offing.)

• Flying to Rome? Know that Ryanair flies into Ciampino, an airport that is geographically closer to downtown than Fiumicino, the main international airport, but that lacks an express train service downtown. Allow for the cost of a cab (which will be about $20 each way for two people with luggage) or take a shuttle bus (for about $13 per person).

• Flying this spring or summer? Stick with a direct flight on one of the major airlines. There are tons of bargain fares out there and you probably won't save money or hassle by taking The Two Ticket Solution instead.

• If you're flying elsewhere in Europe this fall, Ryanair may offer the best savings, as the major airlines shrink their route maps beyond the major European capitals.

• If you're leaving from a small U.S. airport that has lost airline service recently as carriers reduce flights, Ryanair may be your salvation.

• You probably only want to use Ryanair if you're willing to fly through Dublin. Here's the backstory: Few Americans fly on Ryanair because we usually assume its flights will be inconvenient. Most of the discounter's flights take off and land at regional airports as far as 60 miles away from a destination city. (See Ryanair's route map, here.) But what makes Dublin's airport (DUB) special is that it's more or less the only major European one that serves many major U.S. and international airlines as well as Ryanair. (London's Gatwick and Spain's Madrid (MAD) are runners-up, but they have comparatively few Ryanair flights.) Even better, most U.S. cities have service to Dublin that's affordable because low-cost carrier Aer Lingus keeps prices competitive.

• Be sure to allow enough layover time to make your connecting flight—because you'll need time to pick up your luggage and pass through E.U. immigration and customs before you move to your next flight. If you miss one of the flights on these different airlines, you will be on your own in finding a way home. The different airlines won't work together to help you.

• Don't forget that the cost of your Ryanair ticket will be decided in large part by how much baggage you'll be checking, unless you're hardly bringing anything more than a shopping bag. A single bag may add at least $38 round-trip if you check it. (Hint: Pack as light as possible to minimize your fee. And don't try to cheat or you may get hit with a penalty charge.)

• Ryanair has no assigned seating, a method similar to the boarding free-for-all that's customary on Southwest Airlines in the U.S. We recommend that you pay a fee to be in the first group to board the plane. (If you're a solo traveler, though, you may not feel that the fee is worth it to you.) The fee is about $9. (The alternative: If you check in early to be first in line to board the plane after all of the people who pay for "priority boarding." Your chances are high you'll still get a good seat, but be prepared to hustle.) We explained the major fees and which ones you can avoid in a previous blog post.

• Travel websites like Kayak and Mobissimo never tell you to buy separate tickets on different airlines or help you price these tickets out, so it's easy to forget about the strategy. In fact, it's easy to forget about Ryanair entirely because many travel websites, including Expedia, Orbitz, and Travelocity don't include its airfares in their search results. You have to visit Ryanair.com (or a metasearch site like Kayak and Mobissimo) to check.

• Unlike major airlines like United and Alitalia, Ryanair has high profit margins and announced plans last month to continue its expansion. Already, the airline has more than 165 aircraft flying more than 700 routes, says The Washington Post. So you should feel confident that your Ryanair flight will be there when you need it this fall.

MORE

Affordable Europe: Use Ryanair, but watch the fees

So how about you? Feel free to sound off with your own experiences with Ryanair or buying separate tickets, by commenting on this post.

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading
Travel Tips

Biking in Montreal: A new program makes it simple and cheap

Locals in Montreal boast that their city is the cycling capital of North America, with 250 miles of cycling routes and an 8-day Bike Fest every summer. It's an aspect of the city that tourists often miss, but this spring the paths will become more accessible to them and others. On May 1, an inexpensive sharing program called Bixi (a combination of bicycle and taxi) begins, and riders will have access to 3,000 bikes stationed at 300 terminals throughout the metro area. Go online to locate a station near you and check the number of bikes or open parking spaces available. Release the bike at the terminal with a swipe of your credit card, and return it to any station throughout the city. In the past few years, urban bicycle programs have been gaining momentum in European cities, including Copenhagen, Barcelona, and Paris. But Bixi faced a hurdle its European predecessors didn't: Montreal's harsh and snowy winters make it impractical to hook up the self-service rental terminals to the city electricity. The program's designers solved the problem with some technological innovations that earned the company a nod in Time magazine's 50 Best Ideas of 2008. All the stations are solar-powered and able to be disassembled during winter months. The sleek aluminum bikes were designed by Montreal-native Michel Dallaire (the creator of the 1976 Olympic torch) to be durable and easy to spot. RFID technology also helps prevent theft. A 24-hour membership pass is $4, plus a usage charge. The first half hour is free, but the second costs about $1.25. EARLIER Affordable Europe: Bike cities for free (or nearly free)

Travel Tips

Rental cars: Making those highway tolls easier to pay

Renting an "electronic-toll-payment device" such as E-ZPass or I-Pass is now a bit more convenient. The company who rents the things out, the Highway Toll Administration, has been providing the devices through rental car agencies for several years. Now the company has teamed up with Travelocity in a program that David Centner, HTA's president and CEO, says is based on the Netflix model. Here's how it works: When you book a car rental on Travelocity, you can click a link to "Add a Toll Device" at the end of the process. HTA will mail you a transponder (a bit less of a mouthful than "electronic-toll-payment device"). Use it in your rental car and then return it in the postage-paid envelope that comes with the device. The service costs $1.99 for each day that you rent the car, plus a $5 shipping charge and, of course, the cost of the tolls. You'll have seven business days to return the device after you return the rental car. So far, the program is only available in the Northeast and the Midwest, but Centner says that everything is working smoothly since the program officially launched on February 17. He expects to expand it to other parts of the country in the next few weeks. Has anyone tried this yet? How did it work out?

Travel Tips

A few good links: Travel stuff to leave home without

United Will No Longer Listen to Your Phone Rants The call center in India is being closed down. [Jaunted] Tripper Bus offering $1 fare between NYC-DC area BoltBus and MegaBus have some competition. [Newyorkology] 7 things to leave at home on your next big trip Not much love for the rollie bag&hellip; [Gadling] Travel trends in a down economy Travelers are heading to smaller, secondary cities; families are hitting the theme parks; and cruisers want to leave from their home port again. [AP/Yahoo] America's Rip-off Airports Most are in the Midwest and Southeast. [Forbes.com]

Travel Tips

Strike! How to lessen the grief of a Paris grève

Persistent stereotypes paint the French as a bunch of beret-wearing, skirt-chasing smokers who seem to always be on strike. Needless to say, this portrayal is highly inaccurate&mdash;French people hardly ever wear berets. But their affinity for la gr&egrave;ve&mdash;a mass work stoppage&mdash;well, that's still pretty spot on. January 29 marked the first French strike of 2009, and it's already being referred to as "Black Thursday." More than a third of flights from Orly were canceled, high-speed TGV trains were running at only 60%, and regional trains, including those that take passengers to both airports, were severely compromised. Service on the Paris M&eacute;tro (subway) was cut only by a quarter, however&mdash;a major improvement over past years. Strikes like this are a regular feature of life in France, occurring at least once every year. As with this most recent one, disruptions are often confined to only one or two days. In November 2007, however, a strike lasted three agonizing weeks. For those who are traveling, this sort of thing can seem like a nightmare. But strikes are actually quite manageable if you know what to expect. Here are a few simple strategies to help you grin and bear a gr&egrave;ve, and maybe even catch your return flight home. Plan Ahead Tourists are generally the only people in Paris who are caught unawares by a gr&egrave;ve. The locals have been hearing about it for weeks, and have organized their lives accordingly. Before your departure, you can stay on top of the news by setting up a Google news alert. Enter the search terms "Paris," "strike," and whatever month you're traveling ("June 2009," for example). You'll receive an email alert if any potential upcoming strikes are being discussed in the media. Stay in the Loop If you find yourself in the middle of a transport strike, do as the locals and obsessively check the RATP website. The local transport authority publishes regular updates to inform the public of any disruptions. They'll tell you which subway lines are working, and at what capacity. You can use Google Translate to render the page comprehensible, or just glance to see if trafic is normale (great!), perturb&eacute; (uh-oh) or tr&egrave;s perturb&eacute; (forget it). Rein Yourself In If the M&eacute;tro isn't working, you may have to reorganize your itinerary. Visits to Versailles and cross-town culinary excursions should be sacrificed in favor of alternatives that are within walking distance. You can also plan to use M&eacute;tro lines 1 and 14&mdash;these are automated and will continue to run (albeit with serious crowding) during any gr&egrave;ve. As for taxis, all of Paris is trying to catch one, too. Don't pin all your hopes on hailing a ride. Better to roll with the punches and explore your nearby surroundings, rather than straining to reach a "must-see" across town. Use Your Feet Paris is a small and extremely walkable city. Crossing from the Marais to the Louvre requires only fifteen gorgeous minutes. Even Montmartre, way up at the top of the city, is 30-minute stroll from the center. You can also use your feet to pedal a V&eacute;lib' bicycle, although these are in serious demand during a strike. Make an Exit Strategy The suburban rail (RER-B) that serves both airports is almost always compromised during a strike. Service could be canceled entirely, or trains might stop at the first Paris station without continuing through the city&mdash;from CDG to Gare du Nord, for example, or from Orly to Denfert-Rochereau. Check the RATP website before venturing out with your heavy suitcase. Taxis are hard to find on the street but can be booked by phone in advance. If your French isn't up to it (or you don't want to spend 30 minutes on hold), you can ask your hotel's concierge for help with this one. Other alternatives include the Air France shuttle and assorted private shuttles. Our advice is to get this out of the way early and then enjoy the rest of your vacation. Peace of mind during a stressful strike is well worth that little bit of extra time and money.