Is Airport Security Really Keeping You Safe?

By Robert Firpo-Cappiello
October 23, 2012

When it comes to airport security, it's always somebody else's bag you're worried about.  

It's a common paradox of air travel: We want to keep dangerous items off the flight, but we hope against hope that our own bags won't be called into question. I have to admit that, in my case, it means I plunk my rolling suitcases down on the scale and back off, fingers crossed. Passing through security gets even weirder for me, as the folks behind me wait patiently while my stuff passes over the rollers into that mini-car-wash apparatus where it gets scanned for questionable items. That being said, my track record is pretty good. I've been pulled aside for innocuous and easily explained computer gear, and once had a tiny pocketknife (that I'd left in my bag completely by accident) confiscated. 

But the subtext pulsing away under the beads of sweat and crossed fingers in the security line is, of course, that we presume that workers are doing the job they've been hired to do, adhering to the strictest regulations of the Transportation Security Administration. So it was especially disheartening to hear last week that the TSA as proposing that 25 employees at Newark Liberty International Airport be fired and that an additional 19 be suspended for improper luggage screening. That brings to 52 the number of TSA employees at Newark, one of the New York metropolitan area's biggest airports, who have been disciplined as the result of an investigation using surveillance cameras. The TSA cited screeners who failed to adequately check bags before they were loaded on planes and also managers for failure to properly supervise. (The TSA did not share details of the employees' failures.) 

Considering that this incident isn't isolated (more than 40 TSA employees at Honolulu International Airport were proposed for firing or suspension last year), how does it affect your opinion of airport security and air travel safety? 

Talk to us! Have you ever been detained for suspicious items in your checked or carry-on bags? What was your impression of the security professionals you dealt with? 

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading

The Strange Rituals People Do to Beat the Fear of Flying

I have a highly embarrassing confession to make. I’m scared to fly. I say this is an embarrassing confession because I’m the Editor in Chief of Budget Travel magazine and should be a wholly confident and seasoned flier by now. I grew up overseas and flew all the time, and I’ve probably been on hundreds of airplanes. My two-and-a-half year old son has been on 26 round-trip flights, and my husband regularly travels for a living. But still, every time I book a flight, I feel that familiar twinge of anxiety tugging at my brain. “Ugh, I’m actually going to have to do this?” Clearly my fear has never actually kept me grounded, but it’s enough that en route to the airport, I’m always wary about what’s about to happen. Apparently, I’m not at all alone. Even though air travel has never been safer, Fear of Flying is on the rise. A recent study showed that people with Fear of Flying are much more willing to pay for nonstop routes or traveling on a carrier they’re familiar with. I can understand that. I’ll always pay more for a nonstop flight, mostly to avoid the extra take offs and landings. I also have a familiar ritual that keeps my anxiety in check—it used to mostly involve wine, but now that my son most often flies with me, my routine is to read him a children’s book aloud during the more unnerving parts of the ride. (Which means more than one unwitting passenger has listened to me shouting Green Eggs and Ham during bad turbulence.) Wondering if I was alone with my weird calming ritual, I checked in with some friends to see if they had any rituals. Turns out, almost everyone does something that makes them feel more at ease in-flight! “I touch the top of the plane right as I’m boarding. It’s like a love tap, like I’m bonding with the plane so nothing bad will happen to it. Just a little, ‘Hiya, plane!’” R.H., Cliffside Park, N.J. “I cover my entire face with a scarf so I can’t see anything, and leave it on for the entire flight. I look like a crazy person and embarrass my husband, but I don’t care. It works.” L.M., New York, N.Y. “When turbulence is bad, instead of looking out the window I focus my intention on the interior and pretend I’m on a bus. Typical turbulence is mild compared to, say, a school bus on a dirt road!” R.F.C., Irvington, N.Y. “I always buy those nougat candies Bit-o-Honey, and stuff five of them into my mouth upon takeoff. All that chewing helps distract me, and what can go really wrong when you’re eating delicious candy?” C.T., Los Angeles, Calif. “I close my eyes, breathe in deeply, and squeeze my boyfriend’s hand as hard and tightly as he will allow!”J.B., New York, N.Y. “I always buy a National Geographic and look at the pretty pictures. It was my favorite magazine as a kid, and it’s my dad’s favorite. I guess that’s why it makes me feel better.” E.K., Brooklyn, N.Y. “I force myself to fall asleep so I don’t actually have to experience takeoffs.” L.S., New York, N.Y. “I chant a Kundalini yoga mantra in my head when things get rough.” G.M., Los Angeles, Calif. “Right as the front wheels pull off the tarmac, I say a prayer to God, my mom, and my grandma. I can't sleep until this is done.” J.A., Brooklyn, N.Y. “A Xanax and a bloody mary. ALWAYS.” B.C., Otis, Mass. "I always carry "Rescue Remedy" on me in case I go in to full blown anxiety-attack mode. I've never actually used it on the plane but it makes me feel better just to have it." Y.T., Berkeley, Calif. “My mom has always had one prayer she’d use when traveling or in scary circumstances. By proxy I find myself saying it before any take off, through turbulence or if we're coming in for a rough landing: "Dear Mother-Father God, please put the white-blue light of protection before us, behind us, on both sides, above and below us. Thank you, amen." It tends to roll off the tongue if you say it quickly.” D.H., Los Angeles, Calif. “I used to wear the same pair of socks and underwear but they're too ratty now. I loathe flying, but love traveling.” A.T., New York, N.Y. “I always make the sign of the cross upon take off and landing. I try to be sneaky about it. If I feel like I'll be spotted, I'll make the sign of the cross with my eyes: look up, look down, look to the left, look to the right. I'm not really religious, but I feel compelled to do it anyway.” K.D., Brooklyn, N.Y. Do you have a fear of flying? If so, what have you done to overcome it?

Travel Tips

Top 5 Websites U.S. Travelers Visit Most

Studies show that travelers visit an average of 12 websites before booking a trip. Part of our job is to introduce you to new and interesting sites that can help make trip planning easier. But what are the travel sites that rank the highest? Curiosity got the better of me so I turned to Experian Hitwise, which lists the most visited websites by category. While they do update the list every month, it doesn't appear that the list changes much over time.   What came up in the travel category was interesting. Some of the big players you'd expect to find were there (Expedia, for example). I certainly was surprised, however, to see a single airline (Southwest) creep into the top five. Here's the list: 1. Google Maps: 169 billion visits per monthI'm not surprised in the least that Google Maps made the list. I personally don't ever book a hotel without Google Maps open in a tab on my browser so that I can see just how far my hotel is from the places I want to visit. 2. MapQuest: 88.6 billion visits per monthMapQuest can't even begin to approach the popularity of Google Maps, but it's holding steady as the number two maps provider. 3. Expedia: 36.3 billion visits per monthThe world's largest online travel agent is the only dedicated booking engine that made it into the top five. 4. TripAdvisor: 36.2 billion visits per monthSay what you will about TripAdvisor and the danger of false reviews—it's still one of the most popular destinations for travelers looking to plan a trip. 5. Southwest Airlines: 33.3 billion visits per monthThe only airline to make it in the top five is Southwest, one of the few budget airlines left in the business. Now that we know which sites everyone is using to book a trip, I'd like to know which sites you use—and in what order you use them?  

Travel Tips

Dining Vouchers: A New Way To Save Money On Vacation

If you're planning a trip to South Florida anytime soon, especially the greater Miami, Palm Beach, and Fort Lauderdale areas, keep your eye on Destination Meals, a website that offers meal vouchers to help visitors cut down on dining expenses. The website targets out-of-towners with $15 vouchers good for $30 worth of food and drinks at select restaurants in 17 cities including Boca Raton, Coconut Creek, Fort Lauderdale, Miami, Miramar, and Pembroke Pines. You can purchase the vouchers through the website or from your travel agent. What I like about it: You don't need to choose which restaurant you want to use the voucher for, since it will be accepted at any of the places listed on the Destination Meals website, so it's up to you where to cash it in. What I don't like about it: Certain restaurants tack on additional requirements like minimum spending amounts—Fort Lauderdale's upscale Catalina Restaurant says you must spend at least $60 at lunch and over $100 at dinner, for instance—or that vouchers may only be accepted along with a regular purchase—The Melting Pot says vouchers are valid with the purchase of a four-course fondue dinner for two. The fine print: In order to use the vouchers, you must live at least 100 miles outside the Greater Miami and Fort Lauderale area (and show ID at the restaurant to prove it). Meal vouchers last for six months and you can only use one per table. They are non-transferable and non-refundable. Like any typical meal voucher you may see on Groupon or Living Social, if the amount you spend exceeds the $30 voucher, you pay the difference, but don't expect to receive change if your bill is less than the $30 limit. Also note that they cannot be used towards taxes and tips—the website asks that you please tip your server on the entire bill amount—and it's always a good idea to make reservations first, as area restaurants can fill up quickly.

A New Survey By Kayak Reveals the Best Time to Book Flights

Looking to save the most money on your next plane ticket? A new survey by flight search engine Kayak.com says the lowest domestic flights can be found 21 days before your date of departure—make that 34 days before your departure date for international flights. Domestic airfares found within two weeks of departure increased by five percent, and were 30 percent higher one week before the departure date. The international airfares found 34 days prior to departure were four percent lower than flights booked six months earlier than the departure date. The new findings come from compiling and analyzing one year's worth of search results data from an average of 100 million flight searches per month. Here's something counterintuitive; The results suggest that you should NOT book domestic flights too early, as those reserved six months before the departure date were 19 percent higher, and flights found five months ahead were 18 percent higher than flights booked 21 days before departure. Which days of the week you fly also make a difference. When booking domestic flights that are up to one week long, Kayak found that the lowest-priced fares depart on Saturday and return on Wednesday, while flights longer than one week that depart on Tuesday and return on the following Wednesday have the lowest-priced fares. For international flights up to one week long, Kayak recommends departing on Tuesday and returning on the following Wednesday, or departing on either Friday or Saturday and returning the following Monday—for trips longer than one week, try departing on Saturday and returning the following Sunday, or aim for the second-cheapest set of airfares by returning on Monday, Tuesday, or Wednesday.