Should Hotels That Charge for Wi-Fi Be Boycotted?

By Brad Tuttle
October 3, 2012
blog_stairstephotel_original.jpg
Courtesy <a href="http://mybt.budgettravel.com/service/displayKickPlace.kickAction?u=4573938&amp;as=21864&amp;b=" target="_blank">joecruz/myBudgetTravel</a>

In today's world, it makes less sense than ever for guests to be charged hefty fees for Wi-Fi access in their hotels.

A few months back, David Rowan, the editor of Wired UK, wrote a column imploring all hotels to offer basic Wi-Fi to guests for free, and suggesting that travelers simply stop staying at the hotels that continue charging for the service. Rowan understands that hotels incur costs for setting up and maintaining Wi-Fi networks. But everyone can also understand that the costs don't justify the exorbitant rates some hotels charge for Wi-Fi access: $40 a day at the Ritz in London? Seriously?

Based on the widespread availability of free Wi-Fi—in hotels, airports, restaurants, and more—it seems silly for some hotels to keep charging for it. As Rowan writes:

If the local McDonald's or Starbucks can offer Wi-Fi for free, then why can't the world's top hotel chains? Because the current rip-off is unsustainable.

Perhaps, the argument should instead be that it's silly for hotel guests to keep paying for a service that's complimentary in so many other places.

The funny thing about Wi-Fi charges is that they're far more likely to appear at upscale hotels, where guests might otherwise reasonably assume that one reason they're paying more is that they're getting more for their money. That assumption would be dead wrong. Mid-level chains such as Microtel and Wingate Inns have been offering free Wi-Fi for years, as do Holiday Inn Express, La Quinta, and other brands.

The truth is that the guests staying at ritzier hotels are more likely to not care or not notice extra charges for things like Wi-Fi, and so these are the hotels that continue to charge for it.

But perhaps the days of this fee revenue stream are numbered. In a recent travel convention, Rowan told travelers they should simply stop giving their business to hotels that insist on charging for Wi-Fi. In today's world, such charges are unfair, and unjustifiable, Rowan said:

It’s like being charged to have a bath run then getting in and it's cold. Then you’re told if you want a hot bath it’s going to cost extra.

Will you join the boycott? Have you already basically been boycotting such establishments for years?


MORE FROM BUDGET TRAVEL:

Introducing the $450 Checked Bag Fee

Can a Chain Hotel Pull Off Boutique-Style Amenities?

Best Hotel Rate Guarantee Ever?

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading

Vote for "New 7 Wonders of Nature"

Mark your calendar. You have until 11-11-11 to vote for the "New 7 Wonders of Nature." Even looking over the list of the 28 nominees, chosen in 2009 by a panel of experts&mdash;chaired by a former head of UNESCO&mdash;is a fun exercise for experienced travelers. I've was surprised to find I've only been to eight, and my even more adventurous boyfriend has only been to 10, making me think we need to get off the beaten path more often. Some of the nominees you will have heard of, have visited, or may have on your bucket list&mdash;the Grand Canyon, the Amazon, the Galapagos, Mount Kilimanjaro and the Great Barrier Reef, as examples. But places like the Mid Volcanoes in Azerbaijan and Bu Tinah Island in the United Arab Emirates may come as a revelation&mdash;the latter is noteworthy as home to the second largest population of dugong, a threatened marine mammal. I thought choosing the top seven would be a no-brainer. It's not. Reading the descriptions of the place you can't help but be amazed. Of course being nominated for the list itself may encourage travel and actually being named a Wonder should mean a lot of additional visitors. While this may pose a quandary to some sites in terms of dealing with additional crowds, most are touting the benefits of increased revenue and the boost to collecting money for preservation costs that tourists can bring. "Getting to the top seven will really affect the numbers," Paul Gaudet, manager of interpreters at the Hopewell Rocks, the signature sight on the Bay of Fundy, told me on a recent visit. The Bay, between Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, made the Wonders list as home to the highest tides in the world&mdash;some 100 billion tons of seawater flow in and out of the Bay twice a day, reaching the height of a four-story building. "It's like a bathtub that sloshes to one side and the other every 6 ½ hours or so," Gaudet said. The Rocks currently gets about 185,000 annual visitors. Making the list has meant a lot of press attention, and Gaudet declared the contest a positive thing, as he showed me a time-lapse of the tides sequence on an iPad, as we viewed imposing rock faces sculpted by the sea. The Bay of Fundy, Dead Sea and some other locales have been doing some marketing, reminding people to vote. The Masurian Lake District in Poland, a district with more than 2,000 lakes, recently got a boost when Pope Benedict XVI publicly supported the nomination. Voters have to pick seven candidates, to keep things fair. Adults and kids alike can make their choices online or by phone. The contest is the brainchild of a Swiss-born, Canadian filmmaker and adventurer, Bernard Weber. The same 7 Wonders non-profit announced the seven man-made wonders in 2007, after voting by more than 100 million people&mdash;the winners were the Roman Colosseum, the Great Wall of China, Petra in Jordan, the Taj Mahal in India, Christ the Redeemer Statue in Brazil, Machu Picchu in Peru and the Pyramid at Chichen Itza in Mexico. MORE FROM BUDGET TRAVEL: 10 New Global Wonders Hidden Man-Made Wonders Seven Wonders of the World

Travel Tips

When Will Egypt Be Back On the Tourist Map?

Ongoing political violence and demonstrations in Egypt, including the killing of 24 Coptic Christians by security forces this past weekend, is making it hard for Egypt's tourism industry to rebound. Yet bookings are still gradually returning. "We are optimistic even with the violence we had last week," said Mohamed Hegazy of the Egypt Tourist Authority. "We are still in a transition period. Definitely you can predict some of these demonstrations and some of these minor incidents. But it's not targeting any tourists. It's a political situation." Hegazy said that Egypt welcomed 121,000 U.S. tourists between January and August of this year, which represents a 46 percent drop compared to last year. "Despite all of these issues and actions, U.S. tourists are still flying to Egypt," said Hegazy. In spite of uncertainty in the lead-up to parliamentary elections scheduled to take place by the end of November, and the ensuing presidential elections slated for sometime in the first half of 2012, travel companies say they are seeing a gradual return in travelers to Egypt. Pamela Lassers, media relations manager for Abercrombie &amp; Kent, noted that A&K; has had twice as many bookings for Egypt in the previous two weeks than it had since its 2012 dates and prices were released on Aug. 24. "Interest in travel to Egypt rebounded in the fourth quarter with clients who had postponed trips earlier in the year rebooking for travel October through December 2011," said Lassers. Also, Adventures by Disney is going forward with its family-friendly Egypt itineraries. "We are happily continuing to offer and operate our Egypt trip," said Heather Killingbeck, director of program development and operations at ABD, which offers a Pyramids, Pharaohs &amp; Ancient Treasures trip to Cairo, Aswan, Luxor, the Nile and Sharm El Sheikh. But the cruise lines have been less bullish on Egypt heading into 2012. Carnival Corp. altered nearly 300 itineraries this year in the Middle East and North Africa, impacting about 9.5 percent of the company's itineraries, and it has moved out of Egypt for next year. Celebrity Cruises last week canceled five 2012 Holy Land sailings, which visit ports in Israel and Egypt, on the Celebrity Silhouette and will operate 13-day Eastern Mediterranean and Adriatic cruises instead. "Those that have planned and committed with a deposit &mdash; and are mentally ready &mdash; continue with their plans," said Ronen Paldi, president of Ya'lla Tours. "Those that are still in the early stages of planning for 2012 are waiting and will probably book after the elections." More from Budget Travel: State Department downgrades Egypt warning Fares to Europe May Spike in 2012 Due to International Showdown No Online Booking Fee? Turns Out That's Only Sometimes True

Travel Tips

No Online Booking Fee? Turns Out That's Only Sometimes True

Remember back in 2009, when it seemed like every online travel agent was making a big deal about removing airline booking fees (those nasty "processing" charges that can range between $7 to 12?)? Within a couple of months of one another, Expedia, Orbitz and Travelocity all announced that they were doing away with fees. They weren't the first booking sites to do this either&mdash;Priceline and Hotwire had removed their fees on most tickets as early as 2007. if (WIDGETBOX) WIDGETBOX.renderWidget('f105ebe9-8f89-42f5-8996-19cbe88deb45');Get the Poll Creator Pro widget and many other great free widgets at Widgetbox! Not seeing a widget? (More info) Many of these sites still advertise the "no fee" promise, but, as it turns out, that's only true when you book a flight that is serviced by the same carrier. Book a trip that has you flying in on American Airlines and out on Delta, for example, and you'll be paying a fee for that itinerary. In fact, the only site mentioned here where you won't be hit with these extra fees is Hotwire. The truth is in the fine print. Orbitz, Priceline, Expedia, and Travelocity all have a disclaimer (some more readily available to consumers than others) that explains the fee. What's a traveler to do? Well, the answer seems clear&mdash;unless you're booking through Hotwire, if the prices are the same, always choose an itinerary with a single airline over one served by several airlines. If the multiple-airline trip is significantly cheaper, even after you factor in the fee&mdash;that still may be the way to go. SEE MORE FROM BUDGET TRAVEL: Introducing the $450 Checked Baggage Fee Beware of Fake "Direct" Flights Which Airlines Give Refunds When the Fare Drops?