The new airline fee I dislike the most

By Sean O'Neill
October 3, 2012

Dear Airline Industry,

I understand that it ain't easy trying to make a profit running an airline. Richard Branson has often said that "the easiest way to become a millionaire is to start out a billionaire and then go into the airline business."

That said, the recent airline "fee-for-all" is getting out of control. This year, you'll squeeze 50 percent more money out of U.S. travelers—with up to $3.8 billion in fees!

Some fees seem more reasonable than others. A fee for checking a bag might be fair. It helps you cover the cost of shipping the goods. It deters passengers from overpacking, too.

Yet one fee announced last week could have unreasonable side-effects.

As we noted on Friday, British Airways will soon let you call to reserve the exact seat you want within economy class for a fee of roughly $33.

That sounds fine at first glance. Who doesn't like choice? Instead of waiting until the last minute, you can now lock in your seat choice up to nearly a year in advance. British Airways argues that this is a helpful new service that gives it an edge over other airlines, which make you wait until 24 hours before departure to assign your seat.

But there's a catch: Passengers who prefer to skip the fee will have to wait until 24 hours in advance of departure before they can select their seats online.

If most of the seats are assigned by then, you may not be able to sit next to your travel companion or children on the flight. (Note an exception: If you're traveling with infants, then B.A. lets you choose your seat without paying the fee.)

So B.A. is taking a benefit that families currently take for granted—that if they check-in online, they can sit side-by-side—and attempting to get people to pay for it.

This is "nickel-and-diming," don't you think? Seat selection isn't a cost of doing business, compared with shipping a checked bag or buying costly jet fuel. Making us pay for the privilege of sitting next to our loved ones is a disservice, not a service.

Up until now, the airline assigned seats about three days before departure until check in. As reader Mark B points out, "British Airways eliminated the ability to reserve seats when booking flights about three years ago, offering seat selection 24 hours in advance of one's flight. Such a restriction makes seat selection difficult at best when overseas and not able to get to a computer." Now, with paid seat-selection, the situation will be even worse, especially on return trips to the U.S. when—as Mark points out—you don't have easy access to a computer to check-in online early.

I hope this fee doesn't catch on. I hope passengers refuse to pay it, and no airlines copy it.

Thanks for reading,

Sean

Traveler

(Speaking for myself, not on behalf of Budget Travel.)

Readers: What do you think?

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading

The national parks: Best deals for "America's Best Idea"

Autumn is arguably the best season for visiting national parks. The weather is crisp and beautiful, and summer's crowds and peak-season prices have both disappeared. If you have parks on the brain, you're not alone. PBS is now showing the new documentary from Ken Burns entitled "The National Parks: America's Best Idea." This past Saturday, September 26, was also National Public Lands Day, when admission to all 391 national parks was free. If you're feeling inspired to get out into nature, check out these lodging deals for fall and winter at three of our greatest national parks: Grand Canyon Room rates at the Grand Canyon's Maswik and Yavapi Lodges are usually $90 to $170 in the summer. From November 29 through March 4, however, prices start at $82 per room and top off at just $105. (Note there are blackout dates for these special rates around Christmas and New Year's.) The special seasonal rates are valid for single or double occupancy, and kids 16 and under stay free. For bookings, call 888/297-2757 or visit GrandCanyonLodges.com. Yosemite At the historic Wawona Hotel, located between Yosmite Valley and the giant trees in the Mariposa Grove, rooms with shared baths start at just $79 for midweek stays from October 25 through November 24. Earlier in October, many dates are available for $89 a night. Check out the calendar of special rates here, or call 801/559-4884. Zion To celebrate its one-hundredth year as part of the national parks system, Zion is offering $100 rooms at the Zion Lodge from October 28 through November 24. (Rates are normally $159.) When booking, be sure to reference the promotion code "100FOR100" to get the discount. Visit ZionLodge.com or call 888/297-2757 for more details. National parks: Deals inspired by Ken Burns' new doc