DOT Secretary on Spirit Air: 'I don't think they care about their customers'

By Brad Tuttle
October 3, 2012

Department of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood has some strong opinions regarding Spirit's decision to start charging passengers for carry-on bags.

In an interview posted at Christopher Elliott's blog, LaHood said that the DOT was going to "hold the airline's feet to the fire" on its decision to charge for carry-ons, and for the misleading way fares are listed, with a cheap up-front price followed by all sorts of fees down the line. LaHood says:

I think they should fully disclose to people—either if they're calling or if they're looking at a computer screen—in a way that's legible and clearly readable, so that if they are going to charge you, you board the plane and you put your bag above the seat, that whatever that charge is, people can see that.

This idea of trying to deceive people with some little amount of print that nobody can read, or somewhere tucked away, I don't agree with that.

And we're gonna hold the airline's feet to the fire on this. Because we have an obligation to do it and we have the ability to do it.

I think it's a bit outrageous that an airline is going to charge someone to carry on a bag and put it in the overhead. And I've told our people to try and figure out a way to mitigate that. I think it's ridiculous.

When asked if Spirit has crossed the line, LaHood said flatly:

I don't think they care about their customers. That's what I think.

He also commented on Ryanair's recent decision to begin charging passengers to use the bathroom on planes:

I think when you charge somebody to use the bathroom, you don't care about your customers. I mean, it's pretty clear.

Based on the response to our post on Spirit's fees for carry-ons, LaHood isn't the only one with strong feelings about the topic. Here, a few excerpts of the 125 (and counting) reader comments, which, while mostly anti-Spirit, are actually more mixed than one might imagine:

This is just another reason not to fly this airline, which is the worst I've ever seen in terms of nickel and diming customers. They charge for water, assigned seats, checked luggage and now carry ons. Their prices may look cheaper than other airlines on the surface, but add in all these costs, and they're no longer such a budget option.

I have noticed bags getting bigger to save luggage fee, but if airlines push costs too high, people will stop flying. I use Southwest Air almost exclusively, because their very good, but also no baggage handling fees. I would rather see handling fee on carry on baggage, than checked baggage, as it would solve overhead problems, or very minimal size for overhead baggage.

This is ridiculous! As a frequent flyer, I can tell you that I WILL NEVER fly Spirit. If they are that pressed for money, raise the price of the ticket. Its just insulting for the CEO to try to sell this as a way for us to "customize" out travel. We are smart enough to know the deal -- you can't efficiently manage the costs of your business so you try to bleed customers dry rather than tightening up your business. This is no more than a blatant money grab -- plain and simple.

I love it!!! If people had used carry-on for just that -- not stuffing everything they owned into a small wheelie suitcase, there would not be so many complaints. Maybe now we will be able to board a flight in a reasonable amount of time and not have to walk all the way down the aisle to find a place for your coat since the overhead is so full of oversized carry-ons.

I think Spirit's intentions, as well as American, Delta and United, are insulting. Do these carriers really think that the traveling public is that stupid and that loyal that they will accept anything that the carriers wish to charge??? They flunked Marketing 101.

Even though I dislike it, charging for checked bags makes some sense in that airlines could ship freight at a higher rate than checked bags. Charging for carry-ons has no basis in business sense, nor any real practical basis. Smells of the sort of profiteering we've witnessed in other circumstances within this industry.

This is why I have stopped flying as much as possible. The hassles at the airport and on the plane suck the fun out of traveling. I'll drive to local spots when possible or maybe take the train.

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading
Inspiration

San Francisco: Urban ziplining in the Embarcadero

The word "zipline" usually conjures images of treetops in Costa Rica or summer camps (or humongous cruise ships). But during the recent Vancouver Olympics, one of the most popular events with visitors was the urban zipline hosted by Ziptrek Ecotours. Now the company has set up a temporary 600-foot zipline running across Embarcadero Square. The fun started yesterday and lasts through April 18. Rides are free. The zipline is part of the British Columbia Experience, a tourism effort that includes art installations and interactive video displays. But that doesn't make flying over the Embarcadero&mdashl;with amazing views of the Bay—any less exhilarating. For proof, see one local blogger's trip down the line. Holler at us if you decide to take this thrill ride. I know that's where I'll be this weekend. Justin Herman Plaza, at Market Street and Embarcadero. Through April 18, 10:00 a.m.–7:00 p.m.

Product Reviews

Can the iPad truly take you new places?

Unless you've been stuck under a rock for the past week, there's a new device on the market called the iPad. Some are calling it a "game-changer," some are calling it an unnecessary extra. What remains to be seen is whether it will become a useful tool for travelers — and one worth the $500 (starting) price tag. In the effort of sussing that out, I'll be bringing one along with me this weekend on a trip to New Orleans, for the French Quarter Festival. I'll be mapping, eating, and, you know, dancing in the streets. Since these tech toys are only as good as the apps you download onto them, I'd like to know what you think I should test. Are there apps you're interested in hearing about? Challenges you want me to overcome? Questions you'd like answered? Send 'em my way today and I'll report back next week.

Inspiration

San Francisco: The Golden Gate's other side

Too often when people visit the Golden Gate Bridge, they walk as far as the lookout, turn around, and go back. I say: Don't be afraid to keep going! On the other side of the bay, there is a plethora of scenic, worthy attractions near the bridge. Once you get across, you'll be in Golden Gate Park National Recreation Area, at the foot of Mount Tam. You'll spy rocky ocean cliffs and rolling hills, and mind-boggling views. It still impresses me that so close to the bustling city, there is so much open wilderness and dramatic ocean. So whether you walk, drive, or bike across the bridge, stick around. These lesser-known options are worth a visit. By car: Point Bonita Lighthouse Just four miles west of the Golden Gate Bridge, in the national recreation area, is the still-active lighthouse, perched 300 feet above the water, accessed only by suspension bridge. The half-mile walk from the parking lot down to the lighthouse is one of the most sensational coastal hikes in the Bay Area—the rocky cliffs and expanding ocean make you feel like you're at the tip of the world. Note: The lighthouse has limited hours (Sat.-Mon.12:30-3:30 p.m.), so plan ahead. Getting there: Take the Alexander Exit right after the bridge, bear right, and follow Alexander Avenue, and turn left on Bunker Road. By bike: Sausalito Biking across the bridge is one of the most popular ways to enjoy the route. Once you're across, it's an easy downhill ride to Sausalito, a small upscale town where you can poke around the many art galleries and boutiques. Grab a bite at one of the waterfront restaurants, or better yet, save some money and get a sandwich from Venice Gourmet Italian delicatessen (625 Bridgeway, 415/ 332-3544) to eat on one of the many benches overlooking the Bay. Pedal yourself back to San Francisco, or hop the Sausalito ferry, which serves wine and beer and is considered one of the nation's best ferry rides. By foot: The Cavallo Point Day Spa After crossing the 1.7-mile bridge, head down the paved trail that starts at the parking lot of the vista point. The scenic two miles goes past Horseshoe Bay (with more inspiring views of the Golden Gate Bridge) to the Cavallo Point Lodge spa. A day pass ($40) offers access to a heated outdoor meditation pool, a eucalyptus steam room, yoga classes, and a state-of-the-art fitness room. After all that walking, get cozy next to the firepit or just relax in the gardens that have excellent views of the bay. After you're good and relaxed, simply take the spa's complimentary shuttle to the Sausalito Ferry and return home by boat. Monday through Saturday 8:30 a.m.-8 p.m., Sun. 8:30 a.m. - 7 p.m. 601 Murray Circle, Fort Baker, Sausalito, 415/ 339-4767.

Inspiration

Q&A: An around-the-world trip, minus the plane

Writer Seth Stevenson's new book Grounded recounts a journey around the world with just one catch—no plane travel. Stevenson and his girlfriend hopped aboard cargo freighters, ferries, rickshaws, and double-decker buses to get around, starting in D.C. and finally ending up in L.A. after crossing two oceans. We picked his brain for some of his best travel tips. Q: What made you come up with this idea, to travel around the world without getting on a plane? A: I was getting a little restless in my day-to-day life and was craving an adventure and a challenge. I also despise flying—the security lines, the cramped seats, the dry, recycled air. Making it all the way around the globe without the help of airplanes felt like a finite challenge that might be difficult but doable. And now I feel a sense of accomplishment. Q: Of all the transportation modes you used (boat, car, train), did you have a favorite? A: There is nothing like being on a ship in open ocean. There's something incredibly calming in the act of looking at a starry sky or an empty horizon as you hear only waves slapping against the ship's hull. Cargo freighters, in particular, are an amazing experience. You can eat your meals with the crew and hang out with the officers on the navigation bridge. Q: What surprised you most about the trip? A: Once you become accustomed to living out of a backpack, it's amazing how little you miss the possessions you left back home. We'd put some things in storage, and at one point I realized I wouldn't care one bit if all those objects burnt to ash and blew away. Also, before you go: You might want to have a game plan—or at least be emotionally prepared—for dealing with Asian squat toilets. Q: You traveled with your girlfriend. What's some advice for couples who travel together? A: When traveling with someone you love, be positive it's someone you want to spend a lot of time with—like, 54 straight hours in the cabin of a Russian train. Difficult situations will always arise as plans fall apart, or ships are delayed, or visas don't come through. You need to support each other, lift each other's spirits in glum moments, and be willing to compromise. Q: What's a story from this trip that you'll be telling for ages to come? A: Our entire quest to make it around the globe without using airplanes was put in jeopardy in Singapore, when a cargo freighter refused to take us aboard at the last minute. We frantically searched around the Singapore docks—even sneaking into private yacht clubs—desperate to find another ship headed toward Australia. I'd just about given up hope when we spotted a cruise ship in the harbor. I ended up sprinting down its gangplank with no luggage and only the clothes I was wearing, and jumping aboard just seconds before the ship pulled away from the pier. My girlfriend didn't make it aboard the ship in time. Q: What did traveling the "old-fashioned" way teach you about the places you visited? A: Staying on the ground gives you a much better sense of the earth's size. It turns out we live much closer together than we sometimes imagine. For instance, the modern traveler can get overland from London to Beijing in a little more than a week. In the past, Londoners might have thought that China was a different planet. But sitting in a train car and watching Europe melt into Asia, you realize the earth is actually rather small...and thus fragile. And precious.