Should obese airplane passengers pay more?

By Laura MacNeil
October 3, 2012

I read an article yesterday about a passenger who felt cheated by Delta because most of her plane seat was taken over by the overweight woman sitting next to her. The reader ended up getting a refund and an apology from Delta, which is a happy ending to the story. But I continue to think about the issue of obese passengers.

I had a similar experience on an overnight flight from NYC to Rome in June 06; an overweight woman next to me couldn't help the fact that she took up at least a third of my seat, too. While I wasn't disturbed enough to make the effort to get a refund, it was an inconvenience. But mostly I felt really badly for her: She was shoehorned into the middle seat of the three-seat row and spilled out on either side. She couldn't reach her feet, and she didn't get up once during the entire eight-hour flight. Worrisome!

Right now airlines seem to either ignore the problem—shoving overweight people into uncomfortable, embarrassing situations where neighboring passengers share the inconvenience and resent them for it—or forcing the obese to pay for two seats if they want to fly. How would airlines actively enforce the latter—assign weight parameters to airline seats and then fine violators when they get to the boarding gate? (Chances are there wouldn’t be two seats available at that point, anyway.)

The Canadian Transportation Agency recently tried to address the situation...

It passed a "one-person, one-fare" rule that prohibits Canadian airlines from charging those with disabilities—including the clinically obese—for a second seat, even if a seat is required for an essential caregiver. The CTA clarifies that the decision does not cover "persons who are obese but not disabled as a result of their obesity”—but it’s up to the airlines to make that distinction.

Putting that ruling into practice sounds like a nightmare to me—and it still doesn’t address the physical inconveniences for the obese and their neighboring passengers on an actual flight.

Since the number of obese passengers isn't going to shrink any time soon, I like the idea of mandating airlines to add a few plus-size seats to cabins and either sell them at a special premium economy rate or assign them to passengers at the last minute like bulk-head or emergency-row seats.

So where does the burden lie...

On the airlines—who should accommodate obese passengers at no extra charge?

Or on obese passengers—who should pay for the extra seat space they occupy?

Feel free to share your thoughts by posting a comment.

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading
Inspiration

Clever neighborhood "maps"

Jenny Beorkrem is a 24-year old Chicago designer who launched typographic neighborhood "maps," Ork Posters, in November of last year, and quickly sold out. Here's a look at her San Francisco map: [The image is slightly pixelated here, but a real life print has sharp, clean edges to it.] Jenny's Boston, New York City, Chicago, and San Francisco maps cost $27 each as screen prints, a little less as posters. For cool maps from other sources, see this blog post by Prêt à Voyager. EARLIER Vintage Hawaii postcards: A slide show. Cool travel posters from the 50s and 60s.

Inspiration

A great idea: Celebrating teachers

Ithaca has come up with a clever idea that other cities should copy. The town of about 30,000 residents in central New York state is throwing a party for teachers Feb. 16-24—which is when hundreds of thousands of teachers are on break for "Winter Recess." A teacher can receive discounts on dining (such as 15 percent off a meal at the famous Moosewood restaurant) and lodging (such as an $89 a night rate at the downtown Holiday Inn, which is 40 percent off the standard rate). "Bring your school ID, your union membership, or a note from your principal, and you're in," says IthacaLovesTeachers.com. Here's a photo of Newfield, N.Y., teacher Lisa Miller riding a mechanical bull at last year's Winter Recess teachers fest. The ID tag she's wearing is the V.I.T. (Very Important Teacher) pass that can be used to get discounts around the city. This year, concerts include Taj Mahal and Lyle Lovett. (Teachers can get free beer and wine at the concession stand. It could get crazy!) There are educational events, too, such as a reading by novelist Denis Johnson, winner of the 2007 National Book Award. Food will be a big theme at the party. Ithaca has more restaurants per capita than New York City... The town's emphasis is on organic and gourmet food. I recommend that you grab a latte at one of the Gimme Coffee shops, or try a dish of shrimp and grits at Maxie's Supper Club (which offers surprisingly good Southern comfort food for a Yankee restaurant). During "Winter Recess" week, both of these places have buy-one-get-one free offers for teachers. When Ithaca first launched this promotion a year ago, officials claimed that it was the first citywide festival for state public school teachers. Here's hoping that other cities copy the concept—especially some cities in warm weather destinations. More details at IthacaLovesTeachers.com [Of course, you don't have to be a teacher to enjoy many of the events. For example, many parents may want to take advantage of winter recess to scout higher education options for their kids, such as at Ithaca's Cornell University and and Ithaca College. Each school has well-regarded programs in hospitality and culinary training, in case any of you have children interested in joining those parts of the travel industry.]