FAQs about items stolen from checked bags
More than 90 readers have commented on our recent blog post "Has the TSA stolen from you?" Many have had precious items vanish from checked luggage.
And many of you are demanding answers: How many victims are there? Who's to blame? And what can victims do?
We've posted the TSA's response here.
What about the perspective of the airline's baggage workers? What do they think about thefts from checked luggage?
I recently interviewed Scott T. Mueller, who worked his way up from baggage handler to manager of central baggage systems for Midwest Airlines (though the opinions he expresses are his own and not that airline's). He's the author of The Empty Carousel: A Consumer's Guide to Checked and Carry-on Luggage, and he also has a blog. He knows a lot about how to handle lost, pilfered, and damaged baggage claims.
Do airline workers steal as much—or as little—as TSA inspectors?
The short answer is that, sadly, there are bad apples in both groups—the airline and the TSA. Both groups of workers are subject to background checks, but bad apples do manage to slip through and get hired.
Here's the long answer: There's a large difference though between TSA workers and airline workers. Namely, the circumstances are easier for a TSA worker to act alone when committing a crime. TSA workers have a legal right to open bags, while airline workers do not--so it's less likely that someone walking by will stop and question a TSA worker.
Second of all, airline workers generally don't have much "alone time" with bags. In fact, the working conditions for airline workers make it difficult for any one person to act as a thief on their own. That's why we always hear about organized criminal rings at airports, rather than individual thieves.
Just picture the baggage hold area, as a for instance. That's where bags are stored before they're loaded onto planes. This place is a beehive of activity. You'd need your coworkers to help you out if you were going to steal anything.
Contrast that image with the typical TSA inspection area. It's usually an area out of the eyes of ordinary citizens, with inspectors working without co-workers watching over their shoulder.
Which situation is the better one for a thief? The typical TSA workplace setting for inspections permits more theft than the typical airline workplace.
[Editors note: The TSA disagrees with this point of view. The agency's spokesperson says, "searches are conducted often in public areas by well-supervised security officers who work in teams." The TSA spokesperson also says, "We estimate that for every TSA employee that touches a bag, six to ten airline or airport employees and contractors touch the same bag out of the view of passengers."]
The TSA publishes statistics on loss claims. They say, "Of the roughly 2 billion passengers who have traveled since TSA assumed responsibility for screening in 2003, approximately 67,000 passenger loss claims have been filed to date. That is well under one hundredth of one percent, or a claim rate of 3 per 100,000 passengers." Is that an acceptable rate of loss?
Well, before I answer that question, I'd point out that you can see part of those TSA loss reports for yourself. A Kansas City Fox news station made a TSA report public a couple of months ago, posting the data on its website. The TSA report says that about 14,000 travelers a year report to the TSA that items were lost from their luggage. (See the report here.)
But back to your question: I think that's a high number. Unnecessarily high. That's not a perfect number, either, of course. On the one hand, that statistic only counts people who bothered to fill out reports with the TSA, so it might not give you the full picture. On the other hand, the statistic also counts claims of reported lost items. Travelers who later realize that they misplaced an item instead of lost it probably never go back to the TSA and tell them that the claim is resolved.
If the TSA bears a heavy responsible for thefts, why don't the airlines complain?
The airlines did complain to the TSA in 2002 when the problems first appeared. The TSA took some measures to increase oversight of its workers. But the problems are still continuing. You know, the typical large airline spends at least half a million dollars a year in costs related to baggage that doesn't arrive in tact.
You would think the airlines would care about saving money and providing a good experience to win repeat business from customers. My guess is that, in general, the airline execs are distracted by soaring fuel prices, disputes with unions, and other worries.
Plus, in May 2006, when Congress held hearings about problems with airline baggage systems, the lawmakers concluded that there was no cost effective rule or policy change that could fix the problems. I've spoken with the chairman of the aviation committee. I'd like to convince him that we need to get several messages out to travelers, and one of those messages is that travelers should not pack their valuables in checked luggage. If it really matters to you, don't put it in a checked bag.
[Editors note: The TSA website warns travelers: "NEVER place jewelry, cash, electronics, or fragile items in your checked baggage."]
Do the airlines keep track of how many items are reported stolen and how many items are proven to be stolen?
Yes. I once met with my fellow representatives of other airline baggage systems at the offices of the Air Transport Association (ATA). The major airlines shared numbers of reported lost items, lost bags, and other baggage statistics. We all said that we had seen huge spikes in reported thefts after the TSA began inspecting bags. The ATA took that info to the TSA. Some changes were made by the TSA, but my understanding is that the number of reports of lost and stolen items remains high.
Have the airlines told the media how many passengers report stolen, lost, misplaced or damaged items?
If you believe that something has been stolen from your bag, what should you do?
If there is a slip of paper in your bag saying that the TSA inspected it, then you should file an online claim form through the TSA website. If there's no slip of paper, file directly with the airline instead. You should act quickly, though. Airlines generally require you to file a claim for a "pilfered" item within 48 hours of landing. As a general rule, you can file over the phone.
Why bother filing a police report for an expensive item?
First, if you're filing a claim with the TSA, the form will ask you for an incident report number from a police report. By filing a police report and putting that number on your claim form, you may increase the chances that the agency will take your claim seriously.
Second, it's important to file a police report because it's the best way to help catch crooks. Let's say there's a criminal ring stealing bags. And let's say they get caught one day. You'll improve your chances of getting your goods back if you've filed a report. And you'll make it much easier for the cops to prosecute the case. I personally saw this when a ring of thieves at a Boston airport was discovered. Someone in the suburbs opened up a storage locker and discovered a bunch of luggage and tipped off the police.
If you think you've been robbed of electronics and jewelry, is there anything else you can do?
Yes, you should call the airport's law enforcement office at both your departure airport and your arrival airport, filing reports for stolen goods. You can find the phone numbers by calling each airport's main line and asking the operator to speak to the office that handles airport law enforcement.
Should the TSA require every inspector to put their ID numbers on those slips of paper left in bags? Wouldn't that help the TSA trace who opened any given bag?
You're asking about those paper sheets that say something like, "your bag has been inspected." If I was a thief working for the TSA, I would definitely "forget" to put the slip of paper in a bag I had stolen from. Why draw attention to the fact that the TSA had anything to do with the bag?
MORE FROM BUDGET TRAVEL
Carrie? Samantha? Charlotte? Miranda?
I kind of hate to admit it, but I'm looking forward to the Sex and the City movie coming out later this month (mostly because I know I'll laugh, and too few movies make you laugh anymore). Our other magazine, Girlfriend Getaways, has a story in the current issue in which we asked women outside NYC's Magnolia Bakery a bunch of SATC-related questions (such as "Aidan or Big?"). Their answers are here. But my favorite SATC question is from an online poll the magazine did, in which we asked which character you think most represents you, and which character your friends would say most represents you. The results are after the jump. The main point? People seem to relate to Miranda and Charlotte as much as to Carrie. Which SATC character most represents you? Carrie 31.4% Miranda 30.8% Charlotte 28.8% Samantha 9% And which character would your friends say you are? Miranda 31% Carrie 28.2% Charlotte 27.1% Samantha 13.8%
Theft from baggage: The TSA reponds to our readers
We asked the TSA to respond to the many questions that readers posted to our recent item, "Has the TSA stolen from you?" Here's our Q&A;: How many complaints a year are there of lost or stolen items from checked bags? Of the roughly 2 billion passengers who have traveled since TSA assumed responsibility for screening in 2003, approximately 67,000 passenger loss claims have been filed to date. That is well under one hundredth of one percent, or a claim rate of 3 per 100,000 passengers. When an item goes missing from a checked bag, it is often impossible to determine where the loss occurred given that checked bags pass through so many hands. Remember, TSA has possession of the bag only long enough to screen it for explosives. Bags are delivered to TSA by the air carriers or their contractors and we return all bags to the airlines after screening. TSA never even touches the bag at the connecting or at the destination airport. We estimate that for every TSA employee that touches a bag, six to ten airline or airport employees and contractors touch the same bag out of the view of passengers. Are TSA workers the only person at the airport with the legal right to open bags for inspection, excluding law enforcement? Yes. Several of the readers of our blog say that there's one large difference between TSA workers and airline workers. They say it is easier for a TSA worker to act alone when committing a theft of a passenger’s goods because TSA workers often do inspections alone. Are the working conditions for TSA workers more conducive to individual acts of theft than the working conditions for airport workers? Because TSA screens every bag for explosives electronically, only a very small percentage of checked bags are actually opened by TSA security officers. Bags are only opened to resolve an alarm and searches are conducted often in public areas by well-supervised security officers who work in teams. At the end of every bag search, a notice is placed in the bag indicating that TSA needed to open the bag. Are TSA luggage inspectors subject to background checks? All TSA security officers are subject to a background check. What is the TSA policy about notifying passengers that their checked bag has been inspected? Security officers place a notice of inspection (NOI) in each checked bag they open for inspection. Let's say a passenger files a claim with the TSA that one of their items has been lost, pilfered, or damaged during the inspection process. Will the TSA only process the claim if the passenger says he or she found a slip of paper from an inspector? TSA thoroughly investigates every claim we receive, whether a NOI is present or not. TSA’s Claims Management Branch has a team of trained examiners who investigate and assess the agency’s liability when claims are filed. Let me make sure I understand. Let's say a passenger does not find a paper in the bag announcing that it was inspected. Will the TSA still process the passenger's claim that an item was lost, pilfered, or damaged? Yes. If the TSA does not process a claim from a passenger who says that one of the items from their checked bag was lost, pilfered, or damaged, will the TSA automatically forward the claim to the airline? Or it up to the passenger to file a claim separately with the airline? TSA processes and assess the agency’s liability when claims are filed. We will not automatically forward claims to the airlines. If the claimant wishes to file a claim with the airline they will have file on their own. Let's say that a passenger files a claim that an item has been lost or pilfered during the inspection process. And let's say that the TSA discovers that the passenger is right. Will the passenger be reimbursed for the item’s value if the item is an electronics good or a piece of jewelry? TSA recommends that you not pack valuable or fragile items in checked baggage. However, if a claims examiner determines that TSA was negligent then the agency will pay for the full or partial amount of the depreciated value of the item. What is the best webpage on the TSA website for the fine print on the TSA’s policy regarding the previous question? http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/customer/claims/pack.shtm What is the best TSA webpage to learn how to file a claim for a missing or damaged item? http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/customer/claims/index.shtm If the TSA rejects a claim, can a passenger appeal the case to the TSA Ombudsman by sending an email to TSA.Ombudsman@dhs.gov? The mission of the TSA Claims Management Office (CMO) is to reimburse passengers who have experienced damage or loss of their property due to the negligence of a TSA employee. However, TSA also has a responsibility to be good stewards of the taxpayer's dollar. Therefore, in some cases, we must deny claims made against the agency. If we deny a claim and the passenger is dissatisfied with the action taken, they have two options. 1. They may request reconsideration of the denial. They must submit a request along with any new evidence or information that supports their request to the address below. Failure to provide any new or additional information supporting their claim will likely result in TSA upholding the denial. TSA Claims Management Office (TSA-9) ATTN: (YOUR CONTROL NUMBER) Reconsideration 601 South 12th Street Arlington, VA 22202-4220 Second, passengers may file suit in the appropriate U.S. District Court no later than six months after the date their denial letter was mailed. This information is not intended to imply that any such suit would be successful. Passengers may exercise this option if they disagree with TSA's decision on a request for reconsideration. Please note: Small Claim Courts have no jurisdiction over Federal Tort Claims. Any legal action concerning a Federal Tort Claim must be brought to a U.S. District. [Editor's note: Several readers asked the following question: Why doesn’t the TSA require its inspectors to put their name or identification number on the documents, for enhanced accountability? When the TSA responds, we'll share its answer with you.]
Affordable Europe: Florence discounts
In Florence’s crowded historic center, it can feel like there are as many Americans as locals—and tourism board and province officials want it to stay that way. They were in New York recently to introduce the Fiorino Effect, a series of wide-ranging discounts they hope will keep Americans visiting despite the weak dollar. The promotion kicks off May 15—timed to the start of Il Genio Fiorentino, a 10-day festival—and runs through December 31. It provides a 10 percent discount at participating hotels and restaurants in Florence and neighboring small towns like Reggello and Barberino Val D’Elsa. Among the more affordable options, Giovanni da Verrazano, a 10-room hotel overlooking the main piazza of Greve, Chianti, made the cut for our Secret Hotels of Tuscany feature. And we’ve previously recommended the family-run Albergo Serena, an 18th-century building with patterned stone-tile floors, well-worn furnishings, and a convenient location by Florence’s Santa Maria Novella train station. Americans will also get free admission to the Palazzo Medici, a 20 percent discount on exhibits at the Palazzo Strozzi, and a 15 percent discount on performances at the Teatro del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino. Be sure to mention the Fiorino Effect when booking your hotel room and download the voucher before you go. It has an image of the fiorino (florin), a gold coin introduced in the 1200s by Florentine bankers and that enjoyed a heyday as the preferred currency for trade. The promoters are quick to compare it to the role played by the dollar—for now, anyway. MORE FROM BUDGET TRAVEL What $100 Buys in Florence
Affordable Europe: Save on trains
In Western Europe, trains are a cheaper and more convenient way to get around than many of the other options. City center to city center, with no check-ins, no baggage fees, and no extra costs to reach out-of-town airports. Here are tips on how to book your trip. If you only remember one website, remember www.bahn.de. Its online timetable will give you train times for almost any train journey anywhere in Europe. For Germany: Alas, the website www.bahn.de only sells tickets for journeys within Germany and many international trips to, or from, Germany. But it does these tasks well. For France: The French Railways website will sell tickets for any journey within France, and for the direct international trains from Paris to Spain, Italy, Switzerland, and Germany. They don’t make it easy for overseas travelers to book, so there’s advice on how to use it at www.seat61.com/France.htm. For Italy: The Italian Railways website will sell tickets for any journey within Italy, and for direct international journeys from Italy to France, Spain, Switzerland, and Germany. For Spain: The Spanish Railways website will sell tickets for any journey in Spain, you may have to use it in Spanish, but there are some special web fares that save 60 percent over what you will pay at the ticket office on the day of travel or if you buy from an agency. For Britain: See my previous post. Don’t assume you need an expensive railpass, even though they are heavily advertised. If you go direct to the European train company websites rather than booking through U.S. agencies, and book in advance on a no-refunds, no-changes basis, you can find some bargains out there. For example Paris-Geneva from €35, Paris-Amsterdam €70 return, Paris to Milan from €35. —Mark Smith, writing from England, for our Affordable Europe series.