Federal judge says no to Segways at Disney World

By Anthony Falcone
October 3, 2012
blog_disney_segway_original.jpg

According to the Orlando Sentinel, a federal judge has dismissed a potential class-action lawsuit against Walt Disney World that would have allowed disabled guests to use their own Segways at the theme parks. We first posted about the lawsuit back in November.

Disney's contention has been that the theme parks offer alternative methods of transportation for the disabled and that Segways are a danger to the safety of its visitors if they're not operated properly. Currently, only trained employees are allowed to use the device in the parks or guests on specialized tours when the parks are closed (pictured to the right).

It's important to note that U.S. District Judge Gregory A. Presnell dismissed the case because the plaintiffs had shown no intention to actually visit the resort in the future—not necessarily because he agrees that Disney should not allow Segways.

Did he make the right call? It's tough to say. On my many trips, I've been banged around not just by wheelchairs and motorized scooters, but strollers and scampering children, too! During busy periods, navigating a theme park can be an arduous task at best. But from what I've read, Segways are faster and more difficult to control than the above items (expect maybe the children), which can make them a risky proposition.

So you tell us. Where does Disney's obligation to the safety of all of its guests end—and the rights of its disabled guests begin?

Image: Epcot guests take a spin on a Segway during morning hours before the area opens (Disney)

Plan Your Next Getaway
Keep reading
Theme Parks

Disney: American Idol gets a Florida home

American Idol is coming to Walt Disney World as part of the major revamp of Disney's Hollywood Studios (formerly Disney-MGM Studios). Due to open later this year, the attraction will closely follow the format of Fox's popular singing competition. Each day, amateurs aged 14 and older will compete, and winners will face-off in a Grand Finale show nightly. Top performers who are 16 to 28-years old will get to enter a regional audition for TV's American Idol on another day. No word yet on whether Scrooge McDuck will play the role of the obnoxious judge. Image: Artist's rendition of the new American Idol attraction (courtesy and © Disney) And here's news from elsewhere around the Disney-verse: Toy Story Mania: As part of the changes at Disney's Hollywood Studios, Toy Story Mania! will open this summer at the new Pixar Place. (The 3-D attraction will also open at Disneyland's California Adventure.) To coincide with this, Disney-Pixar has announced that Toy Story 3 will be coming to theaters in 2010, while parts 1 and 2 will be re-released in 3-D in 2009. The Year of the Mouse: Taking corporate synergy to a whole new level, Disneyland is celebrating the "Year of the Mouse." For those not in the know, last week was the Chinese New Year and marked the beginning of the "Year of the Rat." (But don't ever call Mickey that!) Meanwhile Hong Kong Disneyland has announced that the first baby boy and girl who were born in the new year in Hong Kong will receive lifetime passes to the Disney theme parks in Hong Kong, Paris, and the States. Flower Power: In Florida, Epcot's International Flower & Garden Festival begins March 19, and will run for 75 days—15 days longer than last year's festival. This year's theme is a day at the beach for Mickey and Minnie. Much like Epcot's Food & Wine Festival, the celebration will include guest speakers, seminars, exhibits and concerts. For more information, check out the redesigned disneyworld.com.

Theme Parks

Spy-themed amusement park in the works

Spyland is set to open in near Saragosa, Spain, (about 170 miles northeast of Madrid) within two years. The roughly $400 million amusement park will have rides based on the worldwide history of spies and secret service, including a mock-up of the Pentagon. Visitors will play the role of a spy, collecting clues, watching stunt shows, and sliding through a water park. Spyland will be part of Gran Scala, a new Las Vegas style resort complex being built in the Aragón desert. Official website. ELSEWHERE The International Spy Museum is already open in Washington, D.C. EARLIER 70 readers share their 2008 trip plans.

Theme Parks

Lawsuit over Segway use at Disney

The case: Three disabled people who like to use Segways are suing Walt Disney World in federal court. Disney has denied the travelers permission to bring their upright, two-wheeled, motorized scooters into Disney theme parks. The background: Disney allows hand-powered and motorized wheelchairs in its parks. But the company bans the use of Segways during regular park hours because it says that the machines are faster than wheelchairs and are more likely to cause accidents. As for the plaintiffs, each of them cannot walk far because of different reasons: multiple sclerosis, Lou Gehrig's disease, and an amputated foot. The larger issue: Between 4,000 and 7,000 people with disabilities move about on Segways. And several of these people with disabilities believe that Segways are more dignified to use than wheelchairs. [via the Orlando Sentinel] EARLIER Too disabled to fly?

Theme Parks

More From the Disney Dweebs

David Koenig Date of birth: October 4, 1962 Residence: Aliso Viejo, Calif. Profession: Author of books on Disney history, including Mouse Tales: A Behind-the-Ears Look at Disneyland; staff writer at MousePlanet.com; senior editor at business journal The Merchant Magazine Earliest Disney memory: Listening to the LP of Babes in Toyland His first time: "Sometime in the late 1960s. I don't know if it was the music or the fantastic rides or all the smiling people, but I remember that Disneyland somehow felt different--safer, happier." Favorite ride: "Jungle Cruise, the only ride that's different every time you're on it, and the only place in Disneyland that wiseguy cast members are allowed to be themselves." Number of visits: About 150 to Disneyland, 75 to Walt Disney World Why the fascination? "Disney has the finest in family entertainment, and Disneyland is the only place in the world that my children can join me in reliving the best moments of my childhood. But I'm not your typical obsessive fan. I love Disney theme parks and write about them for a living, but I don't stalk characters or anything." Most exciting Disney moment: "Taking my son Zachary, then 1, for his first ride on the Autopia, and sharing his wide-eyed delight at driving his own car." Favorite piece of Disney memorabilia: "Photos from my family's trips to Disneyland and Walt Disney World that I keep in a scrapbook. I don't stockpile souvenirs." Jim Hill Date of birth: March 12, 1959 Residence: New Boston, N.H. Profession: Founder, owner, and editor-in-chief of JimHillMedia.com, covering everything Disney: new annual pass policies, rumors about upcoming films, tributes to artists behind the scenes, and so forth Earliest Disney memory: "Being sprawled out on the floor at my parents' house on some Sunday night, watching The Wonderful World of Color--on our black-and-white TV--as Walt introduced that week's episode." His first time: "July 1970. My family was on a cross-country trip, with seven of us crammed in a Dodge van. The day we finally visited Disneyland it was brutally hot, but I remember we still had a wonderful time. I didn't get to ride or see every single thing that day, and that might have been the start of my obsession--that I need to see it all." Favorite ride: "Probably Star Tours in Tomorrowland. I especially like the clever storytelling in its queue area." Number of visits: More than 50 to Disneyland, more than 100 to Walt Disney World (Hill lived in Orlando during the mid-1990s) Why the fascination? "I enjoy the way you're surrounded by detail, and all the care and planning that's gone into creating this seemingly carefree atmosphere." Most exciting Disney moment: "In 1985, I was working as a reporter for the U.S. Army, and scored an invite to Disneyland's 30th-anniversary party. I totally took advantage of the backstage access I had as a member of the press, and wandered across the rooftops of Main Street, U.S.A., looking down at the crowds." Favorite piece of Disney memorabilia: "The souvenir map of Disneyland that I purchased with my allowance money back in 1970." Take it from the Dweebs Disneyland   Looking for cheap souvenirs? For 50¢, penny press machines create mementos emblazoned with one of 51 different events in park history. Get the most popular one--marking opening day in 1955--in the Penny Arcade.   Boost your score on the new Buzz Lightyear ride by shooting the moving targets with the laser gun. Triangle targets are worth the most, then diamonds, squares, and circles.   If it's not past your bedtime, the second performance of Fantasmic--a live show with music, special effects, and characters from Disney films--is far less crowded than the earlier one. (Showtimes vary depending on season.) The best time to grab a seat is as people are exiting the first showing.   Though unadvertised, Disneyland offers a few unexpected extras. There's a baby care center off Main Street with changing tables, rocking chairs, and nursing stations. And, if it's your birthday, swing by City Hall, where you can get a call from Goofy and an It's My Birthday! sticker. Waiters at park restaurants may even sing to you or give you a dessert when they see the sticker.   On busy days, Splash Mountain quickly runs out of its allotted number of Fastpasses. Snag a Fastpass in the morning, even though you won't want to get soaked on the ride until the sun comes out. Like using Fastpass anywhere else, you won't be allowed on earlier than your assigned time, but you can board late. Walt Disney World   Keep an eye out for the spooky new addition to the Haunted Mansion's graveyard: a headstone with a figurehead that winks and blinks.   The best viewing place for the nightly extravaganza Wishes is at the hub in between Cinderella Castle and the Partners statue. The fireworks explode directly overhead and the images projected on the castle are right in front of you.   After a rehab, It's a Small World is better than ever, with a brand-new sound system and state-of-the-art lighting. Now if they'd only change that theme song!